Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-25 Thread Jan Claeys
Jan Claeys schreef op za 23-04-2011 om 02:49 [+0200]: > BTW: I've already seen developers who include code in their > application to whitelist itself. As Jorge asked me on IRC what applications are doing this... http://www.fewt.com/2011/03/whitelist-utility-script-to-allow-apps.html is one examp

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-23 Thread Gunnar Hjalmarsson
On 2011-04-21 22:49, Gunnar Hjalmarsson wrote: > On 2011-04-08 08:52, Martin Pitt wrote: >> Rick Spencer [2011-04-07 18:38 -0700]: >>> 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no >>> systray support for many important applications. >> ... >> If this is a major issue, then frankly

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-22 Thread Jan Claeys
Martin Pitt schreef op vr 08-04-2011 om 08:52 [+0200]: > Rick Spencer [2011-04-07 18:38 -0700]: > > 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no systray > > support for many important applications. > > For the record, this is currently purely a design decision, not a > technical

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-21 Thread Gunnar Hjalmarsson
On 2011-04-08 08:52, Martin Pitt wrote: > Rick Spencer [2011-04-07 18:38 -0700]: >> 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no systray >> support for many important applications. > ... > If this is a major issue, then frankly I'd rather just remove the > whitelist and allow all

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-20 Thread Jorge O. Castro
On Wed, Apr 20, 2011 at 11:55 AM, Evan Martin wrote: > (Chrome shows a systray icon when it has gone into "background" mode: > no visible windows, but still running.  This allows extensions and > apps to work in an "offline" fashion; e.g. a mail notifier can tell > you you have new mail, and click

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-20 Thread Jan Claeys
Jeremy Bicha schreef op di 19-04-2011 om 15:37 [-0400]: > On 19 April 2011 15:13, Jan Claeys wrote: > > Matthew Paul Thomas schreef op di 19-04-2011 om 15:55 [+0100]: > >> * The object of the study was, obviously, not to measure crashes. > >> Crashes are usually quick to find and fix, so any

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-19 Thread IKT
because screen is hard mode. On 20 April 2011 05:07, Jeremy Bicha wrote: > On 19 April 2011 15:13, Jan Claeys wrote: > > Matthew Paul Thomas schreef op di 19-04-2011 om 15:55 [+0100]: > >> * The object of the study was, obviously, not to measure crashes. > >> Crashes are usually quick to

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-19 Thread Jeremy Bicha
On 19 April 2011 15:13, Jan Claeys wrote: > Matthew Paul Thomas schreef op di 19-04-2011 om 15:55 [+0100]: >> *   The object of the study was, obviously, not to measure crashes. >>     Crashes are usually quick to find and fix, so any user test of those >>     would be weeks out of date when publi

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-19 Thread Jan Claeys
Matthew Paul Thomas schreef op di 19-04-2011 om 15:55 [+0100]: > * The object of the study was, obviously, not to measure crashes. > Crashes are usually quick to find and fix, so any user test of those > would be weeks out of date when published. I mentioned them only as > a reminder

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-19 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Jono Bacon wrote on 16/04/11 20:05: > > On Fri, 2011-04-15 at 03:00 +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: >... >> Last week, Charline Poirier ran a user test of Unity, with 11 >> individual participants. This week, I have helped Charline analyze the >> res

Re: Missing panel items (was Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results)

2011-04-18 Thread Alin-Andrei
On Mon, Apr 18, 2011 at 17:03, Barry Warsaw wrote: >>>* The weather notifier is missing. I really like this little notifier so I >>>know when to throw open the windows and get some fresh air! >> >>Install the "indicator-weather" package - it's in the official Natty repos >>(universe). > >Thanks,

Re: Missing panel items (was Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results)

2011-04-18 Thread Alin-Andrei
Hello, >* The weather notifier is missing. I really like this little notifier so I >know when to throw open the windows and get some fresh air! Install the "indicator-weather" package - it's in the official Natty repos (universe). >* System monitor. I like this little applet because it gives m

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-17 Thread Rick Spencer
On Sun, 2011-04-17 at 09:17 +0100, Paul Sladen wrote: > On Fri, 15 Apr 2011, Rick Spencer wrote: > > > > For brand new users? Some of the tasks aren't relevant. > > > Which ones? > > Changing the background image and setting in general. > > On the contrary. Changing the wallpaper and screensaver

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-16 Thread Jono Bacon
On Fri, 2011-04-15 at 03:00 +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > Hash: SHA1 > > Rick Spencer wrote on 08/04/11 02:38: > >... > > Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by > > default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of d

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Rick Spencer
On Fri, 2011-04-15 at 23:29 +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > -BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- > Hash: SHA1 > > Rick Spencer wrote on 15/04/11 15:08: > > > > First, thanks Usability Team! I know how much work goes into planning > > and running a study like this, and how much agony is involved

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Rick Spencer wrote on 15/04/11 15:08: > > First, thanks Usability Team! I know how much work goes into planning > and running a study like this, and how much agony is involved in > interpreting and writing up the results. It's clear that there are some

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Bryce Harrington
On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 01:33:27PM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > Bryce Harrington wrote on 15/04/11 06:48: > > On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 03:00:31AM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > > Also, these tests measure usability, but not their overall impression. > > Did they like it? Find it frustra

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Bryce Harrington
On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 07:08:02AM -0700, Rick Spencer wrote: > On Thu, 2011-04-14 at 22:48 -0700, Bryce Harrington wrote: > > On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 03:00:31AM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > > > * 8/10 people could find a window's menus, but 7/8 of them learned to > > > * Only 4/11 worke

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Toby Smithe
2011/4/15 Matthew Paul Thomas : > *   8/10 people could find a window's menus, but 7/8 of them learned to >    access them by hovering over maximized close/minimize/unmaximize >    buttons then moving horizontally -- which was extremely slow, and >    failed whenever the window wasn't maximized. W

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Rick Spencer
First, thanks Usability Team! I know how much work goes into planning and running a study like this, and how much agony is involved in interpreting and writing up the results. It's clear that there are some areas for improvement in 11.10, and these results will be instrumental in helping to guide t

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Bryce Harrington wrote on 15/04/11 06:48: > > On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 03:00:31AM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: >> >> * 8/10 people could find a window's menus, but 7/8 of them learned to >> * Only 4/11 worked out how to change the background pi

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-15 Thread Celeste Lyn Paul
On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 1:48 AM, Bryce Harrington wrote: > On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 03:00:31AM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: >> *   8/10 people could find a window's menus, but 7/8 of them learned to >> *   Only 4/11 worked out how to change the background picture. >> *   6/10 could easily find

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-14 Thread Bryce Harrington
On Fri, Apr 15, 2011 at 03:00:31AM +0100, Matthew Paul Thomas wrote: > * 8/10 people could find a window's menus, but 7/8 of them learned to > * Only 4/11 worked out how to change the background picture. > * 6/10 could easily find and launch a game that wasn't in the > * Only 1/9 (P4) easil

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04 - User testing results

2011-04-14 Thread Matthew Paul Thomas
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Rick Spencer wrote on 08/04/11 02:38: >... > Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by > default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of development, > it appears that we are going to achieve this goal, and Unity w

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-11 Thread Sean McNamara
On Mon, Apr 11, 2011 at 7:25 PM, Jo-Erlend Schinstad wrote: > On 11 April 2011 13:22, Scott Ritchie wrote: > [snip] >> I think it's the height of arrogance for us to tell a user that we're >> going to deliberately break his application because it wasn't updated to >> use our new indicator library

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-11 Thread Jo-Erlend Schinstad
On 11 April 2011 13:22, Scott Ritchie wrote: [snip] > I think it's the height of arrogance for us to tell a user that we're > going to deliberately break his application because it wasn't updated to > use our new indicator library.  "Still working the way it used to" is a > reasonable fall back.

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-11 Thread Scott Ritchie
On 04/11/2011 06:26 AM, Martin Owens wrote: > On Mon, 2011-04-11 at 04:22 -0700, Scott Ritchie wrote: >> I think it's the height of arrogance for us to tell a user that we're >> going to deliberately break his application because it wasn't updated >> to >> use our new indicator library. > > We tell

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-11 Thread Scott Ritchie
On 04/07/2011 11:52 PM, Martin Pitt wrote: > Rick Spencer [2011-04-07 18:38 -0700]: >> 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no systray >> support for many important applications. > > For the record, this is currently purely a design decision, not a > technical problem. Unity

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-11 Thread Sebastien Bacher
Le vendredi 08 avril 2011 à 19:05 +0200, Martin Pitt a écrit : > > I mean "GNOME" here, as most of the patches we carry for appindicator > are against GNOME applications. > > But it really applies to all other upstreams, starting from hplip, > mumble, etc. Hi, Not that I agree that unity shoul

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Sean McNamara
Hi, On Sat, Apr 9, 2011 at 2:16 PM, Jorge O. Castro wrote: > On Sat, Apr 9, 2011 at 12:43 AM, Sean McNamara wrote: >> As a long time Gnome2 user (and prior to that Windows), I agree that >> not having the Windows-style "taskbar" is rather jarring for someone >> used to having it. Changing betwee

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Jorge O. Castro
On Sat, Apr 9, 2011 at 12:43 AM, Sean McNamara wrote: > As a long time Gnome2 user (and prior to that Windows), I agree that > not having the Windows-style "taskbar" is rather jarring for someone > used to having it. Changing between windows in Unity is a mystery, and > if you are running more tha

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Jorge O. Castro
On Thu, Apr 7, 2011 at 10:47 PM, Martin Owens wrote: > But what is available isn't classic ubuntu gnome... at least not in > testing so far: Seb128 has fixed this, the Classic GNOME in Natty as of yesterdayish is now what you'd think "Classic" should be. For people who prefer classic they'll get

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Sean McNamara
Oops -- I meant to send this to the whole list, not just to Timo! Sorry for the double mail, Timo! Sean On Sat, Apr 9, 2011 at 12:57 PM, Sean McNamara wrote: > Hi, > > On Sat, Apr 9, 2011 at 5:07 AM, Timo Jyrinki wrote: >> 2011/4/8 Timo Jyrinki : >>> There are a lot of bugs and lack of feature

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread nadt
Am 09.04.2011 06:43, schrieb Sean McNamara: > ... > I have much respect for the Unity developers for contributing to FOSS, > and I think that it has genuine utility in the netbook form factor. I > just don't think it's ready for the general purpose desktop. My wish > is for the Ubuntu Netbook Remix

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Timo Jyrinki
2011/4/8 Timo Jyrinki : > There are a lot of bugs and lack of features (and many have been fixed > already as well) and the performance is quite bad in parts, but those > are not as serious as a) crashers and potentially b) accessibility and > lack of any help. Just reflecting on the more recent p

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-09 Thread Kees Cook
Hi Rick, On Thu, Apr 07, 2011 at 06:38:27PM -0700, Rick Spencer wrote: > Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by > default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of development, > it appears that we are going to achieve this goal, and Unity will stay > the def

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Sean McNamara
On Fri, Apr 8, 2011 at 11:21 PM, NoOp wrote: > On 04/07/2011 06:38 PM, Rick Spencer wrote: >> Hello all, >> >> Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by >> default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of development, >> it appears that we are going to achieve

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread ebcovert3
I have to agree. Unity has potential but I don't understand why it can't just be an option for DE. BB -Original Message- From: NoOp Sender: ubuntu-desktop-boun...@lists.ubuntu.com Date: Fri, 08 Apr 2011 20:21:54 To: Cc: Subject: Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread NoOp
On 04/07/2011 06:38 PM, Rick Spencer wrote: > Hello all, > > Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by > default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of development, > it appears that we are going to achieve this goal, and Unity will stay > the default for 11.

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Martin Pitt
Sebastien Bacher [2011-04-08 19:03 +0200]: > Who is upstream? I mean "GNOME" here, as most of the patches we carry for appindicator are against GNOME applications. But it really applies to all other upstreams, starting from hplip, mumble, etc. Martin -- Martin Pitt| htt

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Sebastien Bacher
Le vendredi 08 avril 2011 à 18:38 +0200, Martin Pitt a écrit : > Well, we can always break things harder, but IMHO this is a battle > which we aren't going to win until/unless we actually get indicators > landed upstream... Who is upstream? libappindicator is a free software project not tied to u

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Martin Pitt
Jorge O. Castro [2011-04-07 22:00 -0400]: > We've been transitioning since 10.04 now so I don't think this should > be attributed to Unity entirely, we could have easily run into this by > not shipping the notification area in classic mode. Well, we can always break things harder, but IMHO this is

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Martin Pitt
Neil Jagdish Patel [2011-04-08 11:38 +0100]: > I'll be looking into this, I believe it's because we needlessly > initialise the place-daemons during log-in. Does that include zeitgeist? As a Python program, it has a pretty heavy impact on the login sequence. In previous releases we tried to keep i

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Timo Jyrinki
2011/4/8 Neil Jagdish Patel : > 3.8.4 should be much, much more stable, especially if you're on a 64-bit > system. The entire team is concentrated on crashers and I think we'll > have a very stable Unity by hard-freeze. Sounds good, and yes I've 64-bit which explains a bit. > F10 - Opens first av

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Chris Coulson
On Fri, 2011-04-08 at 11:13 +0300, Timo Jyrinki wrote: > For 11.10, probably something should be done about the logging in > time, with is terrible at least with a traditional spinning, encrypted > disk, compared to normal Gnome. Weirdly sometimes I saw a pretty fast > logging in even after reboot

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Timo Jyrinki
2011/4/8 Martin Pitt : > I couldn't have believed it even two months ago still, but today I > feel the same. When I switch back to classic GNOME it feels inferior > now; I'm particularly missing the super-fast keyboard > shortcuts/search/navigation and bigger screen real estate. I have started to

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-08 Thread Andreas Schildbach
On 04/08/2011 03:38 AM, Rick Spencer wrote: > Representing the desktop team, Jason Warner believes that Unity will > deliver the superior experience for most users in 11.04. I agree with > this position and support staying the course. When I look at the current state, I find that statement hard t

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Martin Pitt
Alex Launi [2011-04-07 23:46 -0400]: > I can honestly say that when I am not in a unity environment, I don't feel > at home. I couldn't have believed it even two months ago still, but today I feel the same. When I switch back to classic GNOME it feels inferior now; I'm particularly missing the su

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Martin Pitt
Rick Spencer [2011-04-07 18:38 -0700]: > 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no systray > support for many important applications. For the record, this is currently purely a design decision, not a technical problem. Unity does have a systray, but most applications are not a

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Alex Launi
I can honestly say that when I am not in a unity environment, I don't feel at home. I bounce back and forth between ubuntu and osx, and when nvidia was broken, and when I'm in osx, I often find myself trying to 4 finger slide, throwing my mouse to 0,0, tapping super, and generally evoking unity idi

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Jorge O. Castro
On Thu, Apr 7, 2011 at 9:38 PM, Rick Spencer wrote: > 1. There are key feature regressions, for example, there is no systray > support for many important applications. According to the AppIndicator Design document the notification area will be phased out: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/CustomStatusMenuD

Re: Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Brian Curtis
Hi all, I think I can offer some opinions on this without repeating what others say too much. I want to compare this to the decision a few releases ago to make Empathy the default IM client in Ubuntu. Then why I think Unity should become the default desktop session and not classic GNOME. Pidgin

Default Desktop Experience for 11.04

2011-04-07 Thread Rick Spencer
Hello all, Back at UDS for 11.04 in Orlando, Mark set the goal of using Unity by default on the Ubutu desktop. Given the current course of development, it appears that we are going to achieve this goal, and Unity will stay the default for 11.04. I'm following up on this list at the suggestion of