Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Kontra
With what they know today, do you really think eBay would make the same investment again? So now all MA has to be done under 20/20 vision? Some business decisions go south. Imagine that! As I have said many times already, we're not discussing the shrewdness or gullibility of the acquirer, but

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread J. Scot Angus
yeah.. I was thinking the same thing, and, in fact -- just to be sure I wasn't having a Sarah Palin moment -- forwarded the statement to someone who orchestrates such deals between the facebooks and the googles of the world, and he said, That doesn't make sense, and what it's trying to

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Brett Lutchman
Apparently, not a disciple of Webster. Maybe, Maybe not, the English language has crumbled so much that many definitions have been lost. I'll explain. Absolve- You simply think it's forgiveness or remission of sin. The word actually means: To declare ownership. Long, long ago, not in a galaxy

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Jared Spool
Nowadays, people assume absolve means being 'forgiven', but it actually doesnt. And by people, you meant every dictionary. http://tinyurl.com/3kggqo Ok. Let's say absolve means to own in your galaxy. I still have no idea what you're talking about. Jared On Sep 24, 2008, at 5:41 AM,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 23, 2008, at 10:09 PM, Kontra wrote: With what they know today, do you really think eBay would make the same investment again? So now all MA has to be done under 20/20 vision? Some business decisions go south. Imagine that! Ok. So where is Facebook going? Is it purely a flip

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Steve Baty
Jared, Everything's OK so long as the music's still playing. 2008/9/24 Jared Spool [EMAIL PROTECTED] On Sep 23, 2008, at 10:09 PM, Kontra wrote: With what they know today, do you really think eBay would make the same investment again? So now all MA has to be done under 20/20 vision?

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Will Evans
Has anyone else read Amy Shuen's Web 2.0: A Strategy Guide and her discussion about Facebook and the the monetization of user generated value streams on social networks? For those interested - it does provide a good understanding about exactly why MS payed what they did for Facebook. On Wed, Sep

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 24, 2008, at 6:47 AM, Will Evans wrote: Has anyone else read Amy Shuen's Web 2.0: A Strategy Guide and her discussion about Facebook and the the monetization of user generated value streams on social networks? For those interested - it does provide a good understanding about

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Will Evans
No - I agree that even while having read Shuen's book and understanding her economic model around user generated value streams - I agree that at least for facebook, they haven't found the model by which they can actually turn that value into cash flow - clearly, at least DaveM has stated - there

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Brett Lutchman
ok. On Wed, Sep 24, 2008 at 6:31 AM, Jared Spool [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Nowadays, people assume absolve means being 'forgiven', but it actually doesnt. And by people, you meant every dictionary. http://tinyurl.com/3kggqo Ok. Let's say absolve means to own in your galaxy. I still have

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Damon Dimmick
This is actually an issue I've been grappling with as it is deeply relevant to our industry. A lot of our work these days is done for companies basing their business plans on social networking and community building sites. This may be a small slice of the work available to IxD people, but it is a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Kontra
Ok. So where is Facebook going? The same place where lots of people (including VCs who couldn't be bothered with doing decent diligence then) looked at Google a few years ago and likely said, bleh, it's just another search engine, is there some semblance of a value statement they can talk to?

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 24, 2008, at 5:03 PM, Kontra wrote: Google extracts value out of mining network effects (PageRank) which is increasingly the primary source of revenue for smart companies. FaceBook has in just a few years managed to create the largest social network. If you don't think that's going

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-24 Thread Nick Gassman
On Wed, 24 Sep 2008 06:47:11 -0400, Will wrote: Has anyone else read Amy Shuen's Web 2.0: A Strategy Guide and her discussion about Facebook and the the monetization of user generated value streams on social networks? For those interested - it does provide a good understanding about exactly why

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Kontra
What you've seen to-date is conditional success All FB needs is a SINGLE acquirer to purchase them. Just a single metric: one company to buy FB. Just like Skype with eBay, MySpace with News Corp, Bebo with AOL, etc. When Google bought YouTube it certainly wasn't profitable in any way and it

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Steve Baty
Kontra, You're confusing the distinction between success for the individuals (founders), and the success of the *business*. I'm referring to the latter; the former is irrelevant to what I'm saying with respect to the business model. Regards Steve 2008/9/23 Kontra [EMAIL PROTECTED] What

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Kontra
You're confusing the distinction between success for the individuals (founders), and the success of the *business*. Founders I cited were obviously colorful shorthand for shareholders, as I have also specifically mentioned them. In fact, I went further to make the point: I bet the

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Steve Baty
Kontra, Not entirely, no. However, at present what you're seeing is investment in the expectation of an increase in share price irrespective of the underlying value of the business. It's the financial equivalent of pass-the-parcel and hoping you're not left holding the bag. So yes, current

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Kontra
Not entirely, no. However, at present what you're seeing is investment in the expectation of an increase in share price irrespective of the underlying value of the business. You're making gigantic assumptions here. It's perfectly OK to establish a company SIMPLY to sell it at the earliest

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread mark schraad
Kontra, There is an inherent relationship between a company's core offering, end user value, and profit. I believe the conversation was using profit as a measure of success. If the end game for the investors is merely further investment, yes they can cash out... but this is pretty

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Steve Baty
Kontra, I'd hate to take up any more of your time pontificating about concepts and ideas to which I'm blind. I think we're a long way from the original point of this thread, so I'll respectfully agree to disagree and move on. Regards Steve 2008/9/23 Kontra [EMAIL PROTECTED] Not entirely, no.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 23, 2008, at 1:24 AM, Kontra wrote: Perhaps there's a parallel universe where business success means something other than shareholders in a company getting satisfaction, but I'm not living in it. Separating business success from shareholder success is so much gobbledygook, I'm

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Kontra
If the end game for the investors is merely further investment, yes they can cash out... but this is pretty similar to a pyramid scheme. A company gets investments throughout its lifecycle, from angels to IPO to acquisition to bonds. It makes no sense to classify a need or desire to get

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread mark schraad
Kontra, You are confusing the company and the product. You are further confusing getting rich, with profit. And the discussion was centered upon profit as a measure of success. I can not for the life of me see how you could consider either a product, or a company successful without some sort of

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 23, 2008, at 12:27 PM, Kontra wrote: A company gets investments throughout its lifecycle, from angels to IPO to acquisition to bonds. It makes no sense to classify a need or desire to get investment as a pyramid scheme. Are you saying Skype is/was a pyramid scheme because they sold

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Kontra
I can not for the life of me see how you could consider either a product, or a company successful without some sort of revenue generation or profit metric. It's quite simple: YouTube, the product, has been one of the most spectacularly successful and consumer-appreciated products in the

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 23, 2008, at 3:27 PM, Kontra wrote: Are you saying Skype is/was a pyramid scheme because they sold to eBay? Even if the scheme of the founders and shareholders were to sell their company to a larger entity as soon as they can? With what they know today, do you really think eBay

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Brett Lutchman
Just a quick note: Google has no plans on making an immediate profit off of the companies they absolve. They are buying out all major 'virtual domain' property and services. On Tue, Sep 23, 2008 at 6:43 PM, Jared Spool [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Sep 23, 2008, at 3:27 PM, Kontra wrote: Are

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 23, 2008, at 9:23 PM, Brett Lutchman wrote: Google has no plans on making an immediate profit off of the companies they absolve. They are buying out all major 'virtual domain' property and services. I have no idea what that actually means.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Alvin Woon
best response of the week on this mailing list! *still laughing* - Alvin On Tue, Sep 23, 2008 at 9:27 PM, Jared Spool [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Sep 23, 2008, at 9:23 PM, Brett Lutchman wrote: Google has no plans on making an immediate profit off of the companies they absolve. They are

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Brett Lutchman
Google has no plans on making an immediate profit off of the companies they absolve. They are buying out all major 'virtual domain' property and services. I have no idea what that actually means. - Jared Spool. It's very simple. I don't know why you would have 'no idea what that actually means.'

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Brett Lutchman
? On Tue, Sep 23, 2008 at 9:35 PM, Alvin Woon [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: best response of the week on this mailing list! *still laughing* - Alvin On Tue, Sep 23, 2008 at 9:27 PM, Jared Spool [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Sep 23, 2008, at 9:23 PM, Brett Lutchman wrote: Google has no plans

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Tim Au Yeung
*chuckles* The confusion doesn't stem from the concept (which is merely another way of expressing monopolist behavior) but the usage of the word absolve. Unless Google's truly gone off the deep end, I doubt they've been going around forgiving companies (what -- you're part of the dot-com

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Brett Lutchman
Ahh! I see! In my church the word literally means To own. Many people don't know this but the infant baptism literally meant To own birthright (the early Roman Empire did this to own the citizenship of the countries and people it occupied) The word has evolved to 'forgiveness'. But it really

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-23 Thread Jared Spool
Apparently, not a disciple of Webster. On Sep 23, 2008, at 10:39 PM, Brett Lutchman wrote: Ahh! I see! In my church the word literally means To own. On Tue, Sep 23, 2008 at 10:23 PM, Tim Au Yeung [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The confusion doesn't stem from the concept (which is merely

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread live
Interesting point: Well done research on social networks and their worldwide uses. http://royal.pingdom.com/?p=336 Inspired by the original, if a little flawed, mapping from Valleywag. http://www.scribd.com/doc/238513/The-World-Map-of-Social-Networks On Sep 20, 2008, at 8:57 PM, Damon Dimmick

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Kontra
I do think that Facebook has yet to produce a meaningful business model. And this is a huge problem. Wasn't for YouTube. Or Skype. Or MySpace. Etc. Looking for multimillion-dollar pay-off problems? -- Kontra http://counternotions.com

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Krystal R Higgins
I would love to see the comparison study of the design reviews of people who only saw FB after the new design implementation vs. those who migrated from the older version. Folks earlier in the thread might have it right, change is what makes everyone else more negative toward the new design.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Krystal R . Higgins
Jarod, thanks for making the point about a sustainable business model. And also for the stats on user traffic. I'd love to see the study of how people react to the design in regards to existing users migrating from the old version vs. the users who have just recently signed up after the new

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 21, 2008, at 6:48 PM, Kontra wrote: I do think that Facebook has yet to produce a meaningful business model. And this is a huge problem. Wasn't for YouTube. Or Skype. Or MySpace. Etc. Looking for multimillion-dollar pay-off problems? Yah. Skype's worked out real good for eBay.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 21, 2008, at 1:23 PM, Krystal R.Higgins wrote: Out of curiosity, what's the best revenue-producing social networking site model (MySpace) so far? eBay and Amazon. Jared Welcome to the Interaction Design Association

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Steve Baty
I was quite happily ignoring this thread until I hit this: I do think that Facebook has yet to produce a meaningful business model. And this is a huge problem. Wasn't for YouTube. Or Skype. Or MySpace. Etc. Looking for multimillion-dollar pay-off problems? I can't but think that being bought

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread David Malouf
But Jared, those are businesses that have ADDED social networking (especially the Amazon case) as a means of adding value to their core commerce business. Social Networks like FB and Twitter need something different. 1) add services that take advantage of the SN ala LinkedIn (BTW, that might be

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Santiago Bustelo
Sidenote: If you visit facebook.com with JavaScript disabled, you get an inspiring blank screen. The source is just two script tags. -- Santiago Bustelo Buenos Aires, Argentina . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Posted from the new ixda.org

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jarod Tang
On Mon, Sep 22, 2008 at 8:34 PM, David Malouf [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: But Jared, those are businesses that have ADDED social networking (especially the Amazon case) as a means of adding value to their core commerce business. Adding value maybe the proper description on social networking; or

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 22, 2008, at 5:34 AM, David Malouf wrote: But Jared, those are businesses that have ADDED social networking (especially the Amazon case) as a means of adding value to their core commerce business. I don't know what added means. eBay, from day 1, had their community and reputation

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread David Malouf
I think we are defining social networks different. Not everything that is social is a social network, IMHO. I don't see really any networking going on in Amazon, or in no way that is really connected. I don't create friends, I can't even say I want to buy everything this review buys. I can't make

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Charusmitha Ram
So an address book? Facebook might have done this redesign as a means to scale its capabilities and support future social computing trends. I think this paradigm shift of contacts being the launch pad for viewing content is important and will be a natural progression into mobile social computing.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Will Evans
There is a difference between sites that are Social Media Sites, and those that are Social Networking sites, although some do both. To the degree that a site encourages basic user generated content, but little else (ratings, comments, discussions, blog posts, images, video) as opposed to a Social

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 22, 2008, at 11:52 AM, Will Evans wrote: There is a difference between sites that are Social Media Sites, and those that are Social Networking sites, although some do both. To the degree that a site encourages basic user generated content, but little else (ratings, comments,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Christine Boese
What if the whole idea of a revenue model is the wrong question? Coming in from left field here, but does anyone ask, What is the revenue model of the Boston Commons? The town square? The implication is that if something does not have a revenue model, it cannot exist and does not deserve to

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread David Malouf
I can live w/ that distinction. :) Again, I want to highlight that LinkedIn might very well be a good example depending on your point of view of a Social Networking site with a business model worthy of a valuation. -- dave On Mon, Sep 22, 2008 at 11:52 AM, Will Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED]wrote:

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread mark schraad
At some level, do you not make an assessment of value and the expenditure of resources? In some cases the return may not be direct revenue, but in good will, economic stimuli or just because it is the right thing to do, but there is usually some measure for the effort and expense. But in the case

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Bryan Minihan
I'm not sure if it helps or hinders your point, but playing the devil's advocate: both Boston Commons and the town square have a revenue model. They both require revenue to sustain themselves (keep the grounds clean, sponsor and host events, etc), and typically collect that revenue not from ads,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread David Malouf
[Death Kitten 2000: How many points are those damn kitties worth?] I think it is a continuum and focus question. I have NEVER used any of the networking features of Amazon or Netflix. The site's value has very little to do with those features. For people who dig them great! Makes a lot of sense.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Christine Boese
Yes, thanks Bryan, that actually supports my point, and I was thinking along those lines too. Often, keepers of online social spaces presume that because there are costs for hosting, supporting, upgrading these spaces, they MUST be revenue-focused, as if revenue is the deeper goal, underlying all

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jeff Howard
Hi Chris, I don't think that ads are necessarily the answer, and focusing on ads to the exclusion of other revenue models is a bit of a strawman. What I think others are suggesting is that users shouldn't expect to receive value for free. I dislike cold showers as much as the next person. And it

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 22, 2008, at 12:44 PM, Christine Boese wrote: What if the whole idea of a revenue model is the wrong question? Coming in from left field here, but does anyone ask, What is the revenue model of the Boston Commons? The town square? I see. So the $496,000,000 that has been poured

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread David Malouf
I thought Christine was speaking generically at this point. The conversation has gone a little academic, right? So looking specifically at FB, I do have to agree with Jared that at this point in history (no revisionism allowed) it would seem that FB has a heck of a big turn to make to make it all

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Kontra
Yah. Skype's worked out real good for eBay. And MySpace was a great investment for Newscorp. The writeoffs they've taken were all in the plan, right? You're confused. Skype shareholders didn't care about eBay, neither did MySpace shareholders about News Corp. That's not their job. Both got

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Fredrik Matheson
I'm a little curious about the revenue issue here. Let's assume that Facebook really does have 80 million users plus millions visitors without accounts. (http://is.gd/2Y6d) These people spend lots of time creating a map of their social network, taking tests wherein they describe their

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 22, 2008, at 4:05 PM, Fredrik Matheson wrote: In my view, Facebook is an elegant ruse. On the surface, it's a social utility that connects you with the people around you. Further down, it is more likely a machine that motivates regular people to connect, converse and share, and

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Andrei Herasimchuk
On Sep 22, 2008, at 11:18 AM, Jared Spool wrote: On Sep 22, 2008, at 12:44 PM, Christine Boese wrote: What if the whole idea of a revenue model is the wrong question? Coming in from left field here, but does anyone ask, What is the revenue model of the Boston Commons? The town square? I

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Steve Baty
The comment (re: revenue models) was made in the context of whether or not Facebook - and Youtube, MySpace etc - provide value as businesses and whether or not they're sustainable. I guess one could argue that endlessly attracting and spending venture capital is one form of business model, but

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Kontra
at this point in history (no revisionism allowed) it would seem that FB has a heck of a big turn to make to make it all come together. FB has great network effects, low cost of production and sales, dominance in its sector and excellent growth rate. FB has raised $300 so far and is slated to

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-22 Thread Steve Baty
Kontra, That (Facebook's internal) valuation indicates a rate of approximately $29/user, with revenue *projections* of $2.30/user this year. Is FB revenue neutral yet? Does that $300m cover its costs of production, operation, and marketing? How long until the investments to-date - $496m according

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 21, 2008, at 9:09 AM, David Malouf wrote: So no one has still convinced me that FB is obsolete. I don't think Facebook is obsolete. (I don't even know what obsolete means in this context. Is eBay obsolete? Amazon?) I do think that Facebook has yet to produce a meaningful business

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Damon Dimmick
This is where it becomes relevant to IxD, in my mind. Every time Facebook has tried to change the design to open a space for revenue generating functionality, the users have borked. The users have made it clear they don't want ads in their feeds. They don't want Facebook using them as a

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread j. eric townsend
Damon Dimmick wrote: This reminds me on a few years back when Salon.com (which I admit I don't read much except for articles by Paglia) was going down the tubes, tried a pay-subscription based solution (which didn't work) and ended up shifting its model. Salon still has paid memberships, you

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Damon Dimmick
Would you be willing to watch similar ads at log-in time? Just curious. -Damon j. eric townsend wrote: Damon Dimmick wrote: This reminds me on a few years back when Salon.com (which I admit I don't read much except for articles by Paglia) was going down the tubes, tried a pay-subscription

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread j. eric townsend
For Facebook or Salon? I (willingly) pay for Salon as part of a package deal, in part so I don't have to wade through ads. For FB? I dunno. They can't even implement a model that keeps me logged in correctly, I'm not sure I'd tolerate ads on top of that. However, I get little value out

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Jarod Tang
This is where it becomes relevant to IxD, in my mind. Every time Facebook has tried to change the design to open a space for revenue generating functionality, the users have borked. The users have made it clear they don't want ads in their feeds. They don't want Facebook using them as a sales

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Jared Spool
On Sep 21, 2008, at 8:35 PM, Jarod Tang wrote: A more interesting model maybe, use the relationship as a foundation of some service, instead of make money directly on it, like, interests group (music experience sharing, other stuffs, ...), and it's more solid to build some bussiness on, by

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-21 Thread Jarod Tang
A more interesting model maybe, use the relationship as a foundation of some service, instead of make money directly on it, like, interests group (music experience sharing, other stuffs, ...), and it's more solid to build some bussiness on, by which the recommend mechanism is critical. yes,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Christina Wodtke
I think the new front page is completely brilliant. I'm less certain about the profile page. These two pages are the heart and soul of facebook. The homepage is more people-centric than ever, and highly engaging and actionable. The profile page, however, seems to wrested some individual expression

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Chris Stone
FWIW, I blogged on it some weeks ago with the intent to compare the differences between the two. It wasn't a comprehensive review by any means but once I saw it I felt like it needed to be done ASAP before I got too caught up in other things like client projects. Clearly, everyone has an opinion

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Damon Dimmick
Genuine question: People are saying that facebook is obsolete Why? What supplanted it? jeff lippiatt wrote: Weighing in. Facebook became obsolete a while ago. Soon to become the relic of Yahoo, aka Geocities. All of these sites will eventually fail unless they address something of value.

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Jarod Tang
Can't agree more on this. I also doubt if it's really make the user's life better ( on keep relationship, yes) from the begining. Cheers, -- Jarod On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 11:23 PM, jeff lippiatt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Weighing in. Facebook became obsolete a while ago. Soon to become the

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Jarod Tang
On Sun, Sep 21, 2008 at 10:05 AM, Damon Dimmick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Genuine question: People are saying that facebook is obsolete Why? What supplanted it? It's not a issue on replacement, but more on if it make people's everyday better, for e.g., by google, you could easily searching

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Damon Dimmick
I think I get what you are saying, but I disagree on the idea of google fulfilling all the needs of facebook. Sure, it can, if all your contacts maintain a website and you fancy searching for their info, one at a time, every time you are interested. I'm not saying that facebook is game changing,

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Jarod Tang
Hi Damon, On Sun, Sep 21, 2008 at 11:15 AM, Damon Dimmick [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I think I get what you are saying, but I disagree on the idea of google fulfilling all the needs of facebook. Sure, it can, if all your contacts maintain a website and you fancy searching for their info, one at

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-20 Thread Damon Dimmick
That's very interesting. You are right, it may be cultura. I have never used my Myspace account, not really anyway. I resisted the myspace surge and was always interested in orkut / friendster until I found facebook, so perhaps there's a relative difference. Interesting point, Jarod. I would

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-19 Thread Oleh Kovalchuke
The primary goal is getting concerned with the lives of others. Listen to McLuhan opinion on global village (AKA Facebook) at 15 minutes in this TED talk on rivalry between TV and computers. http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/peter_hirshberg_on_tv_and_the_web.html I call this primary goal

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-19 Thread David Malouf
I'm sorry, but the cynicism is quite startling here. Can't it just be as simple as 'ambient intimacy'? It's a different model than Twitter or Plurk, but it really feels the same to me. Further, it is feature rich in a very approachable way for people like grandmas and uncles without the

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-18 Thread AJKock
So to step back for a moment, to think about real audiences, users, communities, vibrant cybercultures, and how dare they presume to exist and use tools without our benevolent blessing and permission! What nerve of them! G How dare those cats resist our herding! Well said Christine. People

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Will Evans
Personally, doesn't matter. Facebook is 15 minutes ago. Facebook is useless. Facebook just doesn't have the decency to realize that it is Friendster 5 years ago. On Tue, Sep 16, 2008 at 2:43 PM, live [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What say you, people of IXDA? What say you of the new Facebook

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread mark schraad
Many many introductory products eventually become merely a feature of a more purposed product they are piggybacking upon. There are countless examples of this in technology. My space and linkedin represent purposed social sites... they facilitate finding new music (or being found) and building

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread jeff lippiatt
Weighing in. Facebook became obsolete a while ago. Soon to become the relic of Yahoo, aka Geocities. All of these sites will eventually fail unless they address something of value. Currently they are all riding the plummet of social entertainment. They have mainly ignored their core audiences:

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Patrick Barrett
Facebook is just now becoming relevant to a mainstream audience--something no other social network has done before. Their traffic and membership continue to grow at a pretty good clip. I don't have the answer for how they can monetize their traffic, but I think moving beyond college students is

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Will Evans
How are they relevant and how do you define mainstream? Everyone (except me) goes there - for what purpose? I wonder how they might monetize their eyeballs relative to others, and why they even matter? I argue they don't, and they can't. On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 11:32 AM, Patrick Barrett [EMAIL

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Scott McDaniel
I think we're seeing it become more relevant as they've grown decoupled from people being On Facebook and into other services. I agree that apps and such are little blips in the overall picture, but the amount of social news (and tbh, noise) I get via integrated social networks is staggering - I

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread lachica
I'm in my late 30s and just signed up for Facebook. I'm also seeing many people in my age range signing up including friends I haven't talked to in 10 years. Although it's much less relevant to my life since Scrabulous is gone it is still a compelling site. The draw is completely related to the

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Will Evans
So an address book? On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 11:43 AM, Patrick Barrett [EMAIL PROTECTED]wrote: They are relevant in that they provide a platform for everyone to get and stay connected with anyone they have ever known. I am defining mainstream as non cutting edge (read fickle) users. By

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Patrick Barrett
They are relevant in that they provide a platform for everyone to get and stay connected with anyone they have ever known. I am defining mainstream as non cutting edge (read fickle) users. By appealing to tech laggards there is less risk that they suffer the fate of Friendster. Inertia will

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Benjamin Ho
Wow. I can't believe quite a few of you are so ready to piss on Facebook. I find it quite incredible! Do people really hate their past relationships so much that they have to hate everything about Facebook? I also don't see the relevance of Geocities - I've never heard of them other than

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Scott McDaniel
My address book never enabled people I didn't want to remember from high school to give me daily updates on their political views and dog's eczema, okay? Scott On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 11:53 AM, Will Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So an address book? -- * It's very important to know when

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Will Evans
I am sure that in some twisted parallel universe where there are no books to read, ideas to explore, things to build, people to meet, Facebook is really compelling. Really. On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 1:26 PM, Scott McDaniel [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My address book never enabled people I didn't

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Will Evans
What are the top three user goals when they go onto facebook? Super-poking? Is that a goal? On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 1:20 PM, Benjamin Ho [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Wow. I can't believe quite a few of you are so ready to piss on Facebook. I find it quite incredible! Do people really hate

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Scott McDaniel
We're obviously stepping on some deep-seated stuff here, so I'll bow out. Scott On Wed, Sep 17, 2008 at 1:31 PM, Will Evans [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I am sure that in some twisted parallel universe where there are no books to read, ideas to explore, things to build, people to meet, Facebook is

Re: [IxDA Discuss] The New Facebook Redesign: The Beginning of The End?

2008-09-17 Thread Jeff Lippiatt
Yahoo's old school Geocities, is relevant because it was one of the first pushes to have personal homepages it was supposed to be basically what facebook is but 10 years ago, without all the apps, widgets, social connections. It was more like Myspace in the sense that it was a WYSIWYG editor

  1   2   >