Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-14 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 14 May 2021 at 9:12, jim--- via EV wrote: > A 3 KW solar array would hardly make a dent at my house. I read years ago that when you're considering a PV system, the first step is to review your energy use and find where you can reduce it. Obviously the more you can cut it, the less your

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-14 Thread jim--- via EV
Peter VanDerWal said: > My 3kw solar array paid for itself years ago. It produces all of the energy > used in my house > for heating, cooling, cooking, etc. as well as 1/2 the energy used by my > vehicles. I wish. A 3 KW solar array would hardly make a dent at my house. My about 9 KW array

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-14 Thread Mark Abramowitz via EV
What do you mean when you say “practical”? - Mark Sent from my Fuel Cell powered iPhone > On May 14, 2021, at 8:38 AM, Peter VanDerWal via EV wrote: > >  >> >> If future true carbon neutral is "handwaving", then I'd love to hear your >> proposal for long-distance air travel? What have you

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-14 Thread Peter VanDerWal via EV
> If future true carbon neutral is "handwaving", then I'd love to hear your > proposal for long-distance air travel? What have you got? > Blimps. Takes a lot longer to get there, but it's very efficient. You could probably even make it solar powered. However, I agree that bio fuels are

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-14 Thread Peter VanDerWal via EV
My 3kw solar array paid for itself years ago. It produces all of the energy used in my house for heating, cooling, cooking, etc. as well as 1/2 the energy used by my vehicles. With the rediculously low price on PV cells recently, I bought enough to zero out the energy used by my vehicles. My

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-10 Thread Lawrence Rhodes via EV
EV's 1890 to 1922 (Robert Bruninga)   4. Re: opinion article on hydrogen (Lee Hart)   5. Re: opinion article on hydrogen (Larry Gales)   6. Re: opinion article on hydrogen (Jim Walls)   7. Re: opinion article on hydrogen (Mark Abramowitz)   8. Re: opinion article on hydrogen (EVDL Administrato

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-10 Thread Mark Grasser via EV
-Original Message- From: EV [mailto:ev-boun...@lists.evdl.org] On Behalf Of Mark Abramowitz via EV Sent: Monday, May 10, 2021 9:54 AM To: p...@ingineerix.com; Electric Vehicle Discussion List Cc: Mark Abramowitz Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen There are many more “problems

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-10 Thread Robert Bruninga via EV
Yep, gas and electricity might be about equal for heating, but with a heatppump AND investing in home solar, you can lock in your home heat forever.Renewable adn cheaper in the logn run. Bob On Sun, May 9, 2021 at 7:40 PM EVDL Administrator via EV wrote: > > On 9 May 2021 at 14:38, Jim Walls

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-10 Thread Mark Abramowitz via EV
nday, May 9, 2021 3:09 PM >> To: p...@ingineerix.com; Electric Vehicle Discussion List >> Cc: Larry Gales >> Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen >> >> There are 3 major types of flying to consider: (1) VTOL (mainly >> helicopters), (2) regional fli

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Peri Hartman via EV
ministrator" Sent: 09-May-21 3:38:22 PM Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen On 9 May 2021 at 18:30, Peri Hartman via EV wrote: I've seen a prototype reactor (high pressure, high temp, with a catalyst) I'm all for snagging energy from the waste stream, but pressure and heat

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread (-Phil-) via EV
From: EV [mailto:ev-boun...@lists.evdl.org] On Behalf Of Larry Gales via > EV > Sent: Sunday, May 9, 2021 3:09 PM > To: p...@ingineerix.com; Electric Vehicle Discussion List > Cc: Larry Gales > Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen > > There are 3 major types of flyin

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Bill Dennis via EV
Discussion List Cc: Larry Gales Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen There are 3 major types of flying to consider: (1) VTOL (mainly helicopters), (2) regional flights up to 600 miles (more than 1/2 of all commercial flights are within 600 miles), and (3) long distance flights, more than

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 9 May 2021 at 12:35, (-Phil-) via EV wrote: > If future true carbon neutral is "handwaving", then I'd love to hear your > proposal for long-distance air travel? What have you got? Sorry if I offended, I didn't mean to. What I mean by hand-waving (though this definition is a bit rough):

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 9 May 2021 at 18:30, Peri Hartman via EV wrote: > I've seen a prototype reactor (high pressure, high temp, with a > catalyst) I'm all for snagging energy from the waste stream, but pressure and heat require energy input. Where will it come from? And how does that input compare with the

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Larry Gales via EV
Well, natural gas may be cheaper at present, but it is neither sustainable nor clean On Sun, May 9, 2021 at 3:36 PM Jim Walls via EV wrote: > On 05/09/2021 12:37, Lawrence Rhodes via EV wrote (in part): > > My case in point is over the last couple of years we have switched from > natural gas

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 9 May 2021 at 14:38, Jim Walls via EV wrote: > I heat my house, make hot water, and cook (except for the microwave) > with natural gas.  I can do all that for less than electric heating one room > part time.  I'm in no hurry to move away from natural gas for making heat. I have two reactions

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Mark Abramowitz via EV
This is, and I think, will be changing. Technology moves forward. - Mark Sent from my Fuel Cell powered iPhone > On May 9, 2021, at 10:18 AM, Peter VanDerWal via EV wrote: > > May 8, 2021 10:10 AM, "(-Phil-) via EV" wrote: > >> From what research I've done, I believe BioFuels are a

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Jim Walls via EV
On 05/09/2021 12:37, Lawrence Rhodes via EV wrote (in part): My case in point is over the last couple of years we have switched from natural gas for heating and cooking. It was the pandemic and we drove much less but with the use of electric space heaters, induction cooking, heat pump clothes

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Larry Gales via EV
There are 3 major types of flying to consider: (1) VTOL (mainly helicopters), (2) regional flights up to 600 miles (more than 1/2 of all commercial flights are within 600 miles), and (3) long distance flights, more than 600 miles. For the first two types, battery powered electric aircraft (like

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Lee Hart via EV
Peri Hartman via EV wrote: Biofuels don't have to be made from crops. We have an enormous waste stream with high carbon content. Imagine a process to convert that into methane and oil, which could then be reused to produce virgin plastic. Or fuel jet planes. I seem to recall that Brazil

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Lawrence Rhodes via EV
 No transition fuel needed. As people who use energy realize the cost factor fossil fuel will die and renewables will thrive. My case in point is over the last couple of years we have switched from natural gas for heating and cooking. It was the pandemic and we drove much less but with the use

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread (-Phil-) via EV
If future true carbon neutral is "handwaving", then I'd love to hear your proposal for long-distance air travel? What have you got? Right now until we have something like fusion, There isn't any current tech that can handle it. People aren't just going to stop flying. The only path I can see

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Peri Hartman via EV
le.org/ >> -- Original Message -- From: "Peter VanDerWal via EV" To: p...@ingineerix.com; "Electric Vehicle Discussion List" Cc: "Peter VanDerWal" Sent: 09-May-21 9:47:24 AM Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen May 8, 2021 10:10 AM, "(-Phil-) via

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Willie via EV
On 5/9/21 12:00 PM, Peter VanDerWal via EV wrote: Advantages of this system: Less resources used for batteries (vs BEVs) Less resources used for ICE generators (vs Hybrids) Better vehicle efficiency for normal (non-extended use) since you'll be carrying around less weight All of which

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Peter VanDerWal via EV
> Finally, a BEV is mechanically much simpler and at least theoretically more > reliable than an ICEV, let alone a hybrid with the complexity of both. I > haven't run the numbers, but intuitively, manufacturing a BEV has to be less > carbon intensive than manufacturing a hybrid, and it should have

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Peter VanDerWal via EV
May 8, 2021 10:10 AM, "(-Phil-) via EV" wrote: > From what research I've done, I believe BioFuels are a better stop gap than > H2. Perhaps some day this will be true. However, the major 'biofuel' we produce in the USA is ethanol and numerous studies indicates that the way we produce ethanol

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Mark Abramowitz via EV
I don’t remember the technology. The switch from H2 to gasoline and back was seamless. It was never made available to the public. It was only for technology demonstrations. - Mark Sent from my Fuel Cell powered iPhone > On May 9, 2021, at 1:57 AM, Bill Dube via EV wrote: > > Ah. Direct

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-09 Thread Bill Dube via EV
Ah. Direct injection H2. (Essentially a Diesel engine running hydrogen.) Thus, the low octane (MON) doesn't matter. Most definitely not a converted vehicle. 100 of these vehicles produced in total. This beast got only 16.9 MPG on gas, 4.7 MPG on H2. On 5/9/2021 3:07 PM, Mark Abramowitz via

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Mark Abramowitz via EV
Well, yes - why would you want an internal combustion engine running on hydrogen? I don’t know the answer, but at one time BMW thought it was a good idea. I drove the result of their work - a bi-fueled series 8, and loved driving it (it was *not* a disappointment), but why? Sure, reduced

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Bill Dube via EV
Gasoline engines are designed to run best on gasoline. They can barely be converted to run on H2. In a nutshell, H2 has an extremely low motor octane number (MON) of about 60, and the compression must be reduced so much that the engine makes very little power. The low charge density is a

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Larry Gales via EV
Certainly H2 makes no sense for most transportation or most heating/cooking. But it appears to have potential for long term energy storage (days, weeks, or months), and for long range aviation and rocket fuel, although in the latter cases it would probably be better to combine H2 from

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Peri Hartman via EV
as. Peri << Annoyed by leaf blowers ? https://quietcleanseattle.org/ >> -- Original Message -- From: "(-Phil-)" To: "Peri Hartman" ; "Electric Vehicle Discussion List" Sent: 08-May-21 10:10:37 AM Subject: Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrog

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread EVDL Administrator via EV
On 8 May 2021 at 10:10, (-Phil-) via EV wrote: > Biofuels can at least be carbon neutral, as you can close the > carbon cycle. It will take a long way to get there of course, as the > complete biofuel production cycle is also still a carbon intensive > operation, but this can be fixed over time.

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Lee Hart via EV
(-Phil-) via EV wrote: From what research I've done, I believe BioFuels are a better stop gap than H2. H2 is a boondoggle. I just can't find a use case that makes sense, it's poor systemic efficiency, and super-high infrastructure cost take it out of consideration. I'm worried that the use

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread (-Phil-) via EV
From what research I've done, I believe BioFuels are a better stop gap than H2. H2 is a boondoggle. I just can't find a use case that makes sense, it's poor systemic efficiency, and super-high infrastructure cost take it out of consideration. We'll still need some kind of energy dense solution

Re: [EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Peri Hartman via EV
Resending... didn't go through. << Annoyed by leaf blowers ? https://quietcleanseattle.org/ >> -- Original Message -- From: "Peri Hartman" To: "Electric Vehicle Discussion List" Sent: 07-May-21 6:27:44 PM Subject: opinion article on hydrogen This article claims that producing

[EVDL] opinion article on hydrogen

2021-05-08 Thread Peri Hartman via EV
This article claims that producing hydrogen will remain too expensive and therefore people will continue to choose to use natural gas if there isn't an electric alternative. It also mentions the poor efficiency of producing it. Using hydrogen fuel risks locking in reliance on fossil fuels,