[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, Thanks for this interesting synopsis. It helps put the book and your thoughts on the book into perspective. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, salik888 novelidea8@... wrote: Joe and Bill I am reading the book, and I get where Mr Kim is coming from . . . contextually

[Zen] Re: becoming a zen chaplain

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Rosy, You might like to talk with a Buddhist Chaplain. My friend Claude d'Estree has been a Buddhist Chaplain at Harvard University, and at the University of Arizona. He is a senior student in America of the Dalai Lama, and a lineage holder. He is also a practitioner of Korean Zen (Son).

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Is there a difference between a teacher giving lessons to students for $120 and one giving them in return for a blowjob? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Merle, The biographer interviewed some 427 people who knew John while alive. I call that

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Chris, Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: That reluctance to challenge the prevailing conditions is why human history has been so awful until so recently, and is only now slightly better. You -- yes, and even You -- have to look at it with the eyes of Compassion and Wisdom, not with the

Re: [Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
According to contemporary standards, why yes there is. Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Feb 20, 2013 12:14 AM, Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org wrote: Is there a difference between a teacher giving lessons to students for $120 and one giving them in return for a blowjob? ...Bill! --- In

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Ha! I criticize your statement here. The fellow gets deep down into the basement, and sees the treasures in the wine cellar, then says that the stairway that led him down there and bore all his weight, step by step, safely!, and then removed all his weight, is fluff, extraneous, and

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, I don't understand the wording. Is something garbled, there? --Joe Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Is there a difference between a teacher giving lessons to students for $120 and one giving them in return for a blowjob? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe

[Zen] I have never done any sadhana

2013-02-20 Thread SURESH JAGADEESAN
From Ramana Maharishi - (very thought provoking) “I have never done any sadhana. I did not even know what sadhana was. Only long afterwards I came to know what sadhana was and how many different kinds of it there were. Only if there was a goal to attain, I should have made sadhana to attain that

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Chris, and what is that? The fact $120 is a lot more money than you'd have to pay for a blowjob? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: According to contemporary standards, why yes there is. Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Feb 20, 2013 12:14 AM,

[Zen] Re: I have never done any sadhana

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Suresh, Thank you! It's beautiful!, beautiful. The only thing better than a first-hand account is your own account. --Joe SURESH JAGADEESAN varamtha@... wrote: From Ramana Maharishi - (very thought provoking) I have never done any sadhana. I did not even know what sadhana was. Only

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, You speak the truth about the way I discovered/uncovered Just THIS! But my reference in this thread was to the ESSENCE of zen, not the various routes you can or should try taking to discover/uncover the essence. As I am sure you know zen literature sometimes refers to what I call 'fluff'

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
In re-reading it I could have made it clearer by either: - repeating the word 'lessons' after the word 'them' in the latter part of the sentence. - using the noun 'lessons' instead of the pronoun 'them' in the latter part of the sentence. Better now? ...Bill! --- In

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
Thanks, --Chris ch...@austin-lane.net +1-301-270-6524 On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:33 AM, Joe desert_woodwor...@yahoo.com wrote: Chris, Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: That reluctance to challenge the prevailing conditions is why human history has been so awful until so recently,

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, The secretive and guarded 'wine cellar' analogy is misleading. We're selling water by the river, remember? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Bill!, You've had a taste of my tough love. See?, that sweet stuff was not so bad. And I see

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Most of what I write he is purely extemporaneous. I don't often re-read and edit it. Sometimes I start a sentence with one thought in mind but that changes a little before the end of the sentence. The result sometimes is not representative of my best rhetoric or prose. If it continues

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Chris, Me? Rather give a blowjob than pay a [monetary] fee? I guess that all depends on the fee...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:54 AM, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Chris, and what is that? The fact $120 is a lot more

Re: [Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
A picture of a rice cake is not a rice cake, but it's still a rice cake. It should be painted with attention. Thanks, --Chris ch...@austin-lane.net +1-301-270-6524 On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 1:29 AM, Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org wrote: Chris, Me? Rather give a blowjob than pay a [monetary]

Re: [Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
Says someone that probably hasn't sent typo free email in 4 weeks, judging from the samples I do reread when people reply to them. Thanks, --Chris ch...@austin-lane.net +1-301-270-6524 On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 1:33 AM, Chris Austin-Lane ch...@austin-lane.netwrote: A picture of a rice cake is

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Yeah, you say that, but you're not hoarding water! I may be, but I'm the guy in the desert. Anyway, it *was* my turn to mislead. Else, where's the fun in Good Cop, Bad Cop? (Gotta keep up my role if I want my check from the Precinct at the end of two weeks). --Joe PS I like the

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
This is not a reply to Chris' recent post, A picture of a rice cake is not a rice cake, but it's still a rice cake. It should be painted with attention.

Re: [Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
Arg, as I said typo city - It is still a picture of a rice cake. Thanks, --Chris ch...@austin-lane.net +1-301-270-6524 On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 1:39 AM, Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org wrote: This is not a reply to Chris' recent post, A picture of a rice cake is not a rice cake, but it's

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Chris, Man, you weren't kidding about the art lessons. --Joe PS I think Bill! gives it attention just fine, and I *don't* want for him to have to feel he has to now start using ...POLISH. I can't even SPEAK Polish. And polish is for woodworkers like me. Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote:

[Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Merle is gonna love that, she is. Nice post! --Joe PS I'm glad I never learned to smoke. Whenever someone offered me a cigarette, I usually accepted, say, in college, anyway. I always choked, and my friend or new acquaintance would laugh. I've lost too many friends to smoking,

[Zen] Re: I have never done any sadhana

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Think about it before you begin a practice of some kind, I think Suresh may mean. Maharshi is saying that all he did was begin to sit with his eyes open, rather than as he did previously, with eyes closed. So he changed to sitting with eyes open, as we do in zazen. And, at some point

[Zen] Re: I have never done any sadhana

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Thanks! You're post below was very thought provoking...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Bill!, Think about it before you begin a practice of some kind, I think Suresh may mean. Maharshi is saying that all he did was begin to sit with his

Re: [Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
And Merle is the person here who knows a Zen fraud when she hears of one, contrary to the true believer zennists among us... Thanks Merle! Edgar On Feb 19, 2013, at 10:41 PM, Merle Lester wrote: edgar is a steady ship who sails the 7 seas so careful to not fall overboard or be

[Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Edgar, I know who Merle is, but what is the 'Zen fraud' to which you're referring, and who do you consider 'true believer zennists' (or how do you characterize them) on this Yahoo! Zen Forum which is dedicated to discussions on Zen Buddhism? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Edgar

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Hi Siska, Thanks for the cogent question All that exists is reality, so in that sense all that exists is Zen. However reality is a magician's trick where things are not as they appear. If we take the illusion of the trick as reality we are unenlightened, but if we take the exact same

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Siska, Those politically correct types who see racism where it doesn't exist are NOT enlightened beings because they are still living in the world of illusion their own minds construct for them... Edgar On Feb 20, 2013, at 12:43 AM, siska_...@yahoo.com wrote: Joe, Racism is part of Zen

Re: [Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, Wasn't referring to you... Edgar On Feb 20, 2013, at 7:37 AM, Bill! wrote: Edgar, I know who Merle is, but what is the 'Zen fraud' to which you're referring, and who do you consider 'true believer zennists' (or how do you characterize them) on this Yahoo! Zen Forum which is

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread mike
Bill!, A metaphysical wrestling match sounds awesome. Imagine Hulk Hogan and Jesse Ventura facing-off against each other over whether Wittgenstein was correct in his theory that the world is made up of facts and not objects. Maybe I should start our future dialogues with I'm gonna break you..

RE: [Zen] Re: Zen Groups Distressed by Accusations Against Teacher

2013-02-20 Thread uerusuboyo
Joe, br/br/Garbled or 'gobbled'? ; )br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPhone

[Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Edgar, It's okay if you were. You did already say you thought I was 'orthodox' or something like that. No big deal. What is the 'Zen fraud' to which you referred? The sex thingy? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Bill, Wasn't referring to

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Mike, Satori (realization/manifestation of Buddha Nature) is awareness, but that awareness is not the awareness of a subject, nor is it an awareness of an object. It is just direct, pure, holistic awareness. Just THIS! I usually refer to this holistic awareness just as 'experience', since

Re: [Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Subhana is a candidate. Ask Merle... Edgar On Feb 20, 2013, at 8:51 AM, Bill! wrote: Edgar, It's okay if you were. You did already say you thought I was 'orthodox' or something like that. No big deal. What is the 'Zen fraud' to which you referred? The sex thingy? ...Bill! ---

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread mike
Bill!, I think we're now beginning to say the same thing which is a good thing! That holistic-awareness to me is just the same as my 'subjective-objective' definition. The only thing I'd question is that when you say, ..not the awareness of a subject.. - I'd say the subject is seen thru (as

[Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Edgar, Oh, that Subhana. I have nothing substantive to add to that discussion. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Subhana is a candidate. Ask Merle... Edgar On Feb 20, 2013, at 8:51 AM, Bill! wrote: Edgar, It's okay if you were.

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Mike, Okay, I can live with 'holistic experience in which subject/object (dualism) is seen to be illusory. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, mike uerusuboyo@... wrote: Bill!, I think we're now beginning to say the same thing which is a good thing! That holistic-awareness to

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Mike, I just went to bed but had to get up to basically retract what I had written below. During 'kensho' or 'satori' there is ONLY pure holistic awareness; what I call experience, and sometimes use the unnecessary qualifiers of pure, direct, immediate and sensory. There is NO awareness of

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread salik888
taking The Great Heart Wisdom Sutra into consideration, isn't form and emptiness the same, thus illusion would not be less or more -- I am realistically! /\ zendervish --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Zendervish, No, there are absolutely no intrinsic (could

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread salik888
I am glad /\ zendervish --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Zendervish, Thanks for this interesting synopsis. It helps put the book and your thoughts on the book into perspective. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, salik888 novelidea8@ wrote:

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread salik888
Bill In reality isn't it all the same thing? Phenomena, enlightenment, taking out the garbage, zazen, one-eyed dogs, etc is all Dharma? Questions about questions? Assertions about assertions? Buddha Nature /\ zendervish --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote:

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread salik888
Mike and Bill, Further in my reading of Kim's book. The encounter (experience as Bill says) with impermanence and emptiness of form is, or appears to be the so-called `mystical' realization for Dogen. There are glimpses of it early for Dogen, like his mother's funeral, seeing the incense rise

[Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Edgar, I doubt that Merle was complimenting you on being a Zen fraud, but have it your way. What's a Zen fraud? A relative of Sigmoid Frond? Something else in Merle's list of specious zen things, and good for a hoot. --Joe Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: And Merle is the person here who

[Zen] Re: on being dumb

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Aww-w, ...not even at a penny a post? --Joe Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Edgar, Oh, that Subhana. I have nothing substantive to add to that discussion. Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you recently have read or are reading! Talk

[Zen] things are not always as they seem

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 good one ...100 marks to those who know who the artist is merle   This is not a reply to Chris' recent post, A picture of a rice cake is not a rice cake, but it's still a rice cake.  It should be painted with attention.

[Zen] Re: things are not always as they seem

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Merle, Guessing Marcel Duchamp. God morning to you. Snow! in the desert today. A rare day. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  good one ...100 marks to those who know who the artist is merle   This is not a reply to Chris' recent post, A picture of a rice cake is not a

[Zen] purity

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
   how are we going to ever be pure and true to zen if we are always busy polishing... goodness me..  surely it's the moment the very essence of existence .. that tiny second that we relish.. sifting and policing the moment will destroy the joy of being...  constantly chattering in our minds

[Zen] ready to take

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 where there is hope of a dollar  folk are there with their mouths open wide and their palms greased ready to take... be it zen or be it blow jobs.. .that is the nature of the beast as it stands today.. merle   On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 12:54 AM, Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org wrote: Chris,

Re: [Zen] Re: red road

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 please enhance this !..merle   Merle, The moonlight of Samadhi. The Great Golden Ocean Seal samadhi, for example. I recommend Zen practice to Painters, regularly. A few of them have taken it up. They know I would not mislead them. There's gold in this path, Merle. You are it. But

Re: [Zen] Re: Tim Flach vs. Icecream; WAS: Tim Flach

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 did you look at this website joe?..merle   Merle, I want icecream. Is it icecream? I heard today that there is a country in the world where the _per capita_ consumption of icecream amounts to US $700 equivalent. Does anybody know where that is? --Joe Merle Lester wrote: THIS IS AN

Re: [Zen] Re: things are not always as they seem

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 correct!  so beautiful to see the snow..in the desert..now that is a treat!... we have grey clouds and the showers looming at 10:24am..merle   Merle, Guessing Marcel Duchamp. God morning to you. Snow! in the desert today. A rare day. --Joe Merle Lester wrote:  good one ...100 marks

[Zen] oneness

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 bill.. which aldous huxley book have you read? oneness just is  we just are however we forget we are merle   Mike, I really don't want to get in a metaphysical wrestling match with you, and I have read both William James and Aldous Huxley and do appreciate the state they are referring to

[Zen] Re: purity

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Merle, I also gave Bill! similar leave and dispensation (but no compensation; and no taxation without perspiration). ;-) But our group-made gallery is not the Louvre, here. It is a (largely) text-based communications medium. I could not suggest polishing grammar or even punctuation, for

[Zen] chaining birds

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 joe.. the bird is free.. never chain the bird.. in so doing we chain ourselves  i am not a bird watcher as such.. even watching birds do we destroy their freedom to be?.. merle   Merle, I leave the birds in the bush because I am so shy and retiring, like you, who won't even email a

[Zen] Re: red road

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Dear Merle, Merle wrote: please enhance this ! Done! For YOURSELF, though, practice will do it for YOU, too. See, I can't operate a wrench at such a distance, nor direct my feather-duster through all that wind at the Equator. Contact your locals, and they can help, just in the same kind of

[Zen] drug culture

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 drugs ..drugs drugs...the world of drugs that we encounter now is quite alarming.. a pill for this a pill for that..  always popping pills ..big business our society now..  occasionally i taketh of the wine that jesus spoke of and find the mediative quality enhances perception.. cultures

Re: [Zen] Re: red road

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 dear joe..of course i am interested...and i thank you for your never ending faith that one day i may find a way...merle     Dear Merle, Merle wrote: please enhance this ! Done! For YOURSELF, though, practice will do it for YOU, too. See, I can't operate a wrench at such a distance,

[Zen] Re: Tim Flach vs. Icecream; WAS: Tim Flach

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Yes, Merle, thank you very much, I did open said link. I became scared, though, and actually horrified. I couldn't look at more than one image. This is one reason I'm usually quite tentative about opening links, especially those without good strong motivation given to do so, as in it's given

[Zen] Re: chaining birds

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Merle, I study them from life because I paint them. I don't know why I do this. And I'm new at both things, so I don't know how long either thing will last. I love knowing their lovely names, and I love reciting their names. Like reciting the names of the stars at night. I hope you know

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread siska_cen
Hi Bill, What is the fundamental importance of the premise All beings have Buddha Nature if one is not aware of it? There is Buddha Nature, but some people are aware of it and some don't. So, what does this 'embedded' Buddha Nature implies? It doesn't feel right, feels like duality also, but

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, You asked if there were any differences between illusion and dharma, and I answered (offered my opinion) 'no'. So what's your point? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, salik888 novelidea8@... wrote: taking The Great Heart Wisdom Sutra into consideration, isn't form and

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread siska_cen
Hi Edgar, So when we see unenlightened beings, is that experience reality or illusion? Similar question, when we see ourselves as unenlightened, is that reality or illusion? How do you tell which is what? How do you know which is what? Siska -Original Message- From: Edgar Owen

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread siska_cen
Edgar, Aren't we ALL not enlightened beings, regardless what types? Or, at least I'm speaking for myself. Siska --Original Message-- From: Edgar Owen Sender: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com ReplyTo: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Subject: Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, If you want to continue this discussion I'll have to know what you mean when you use the term 'dharma'. I looked it up in Wikipedia and their definition of the Buddhist concept of 'dharma' has 4 parts: 1. The state of Nature as it is (yath#257; bh#363;ta) 2. The Laws of Nature

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Chris, Is that so? ;-) --Joe Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: Two words to remember about Zen: Not Always So. Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you recently have read or are reading! Talk about it today!Yahoo! Groups Links * To visit

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, It does sound like an interesting book. I especially liked the description of 'glimpses' of Buddha Nature before kensho/satori. Of course those 'glimpses' only became significant AFTER kensho/satori because it was then the memory of them were put into context. I think we've all

[Zen] Re: things are not always as they seem

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Merle, It was of course the great surrealist René Magritte. Just credit my account with the 100 marks...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  good one ...100 marks to those who know who the artist is merle   This is not a reply to Chris' recent

[Zen] Re: oneness

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Merle, Brave New World Eyeless in Gaza Island (halfway) The Perennial Philosophy The Doors of Perception (my favorite) ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  bill.. which aldous huxley book have you read? oneness just is  we just are

Re: [Zen] Re: Tim Flach vs. Icecream; WAS: Tim Flach

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 huh..i am confused...don't you have virus protection on your computer?... pc i presume?..merle   Yes, Merle, thank you very much, I did open said link. I became scared, though, and actually horrified. I couldn't look at more than one image. This is one reason I'm usually quite tentative

Re: [Zen] Re: oneness

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 yes..my fav too doors of perception plus perennial philosophy...i love aldous huxley..genius!..merle   Merle, Brave New World Eyeless in Gaza Island (halfway) The Perennial Philosophy The Doors of Perception (my favorite) ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester wrote:

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Mike, Thanks. I have two comments on this: 1. It was not MY experience that kensho/satori included an awareness of subject/object (illusion). 2. IMO, and to resolve the writings you cite with my experience, I believe the passages refer to observations made and conclusions reached AFTER

Re: [Zen] Re: chaining birds

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 i love all haiku...so simple and to the point!.. how delightfully caring you are joe.. the child in you is still there i see... the beauty of the bird is the joy of seeing it in flight.. if only we had wings then we too might be liberated ... however we are chained to the ground...  

Re: [Zen] Re: things are not always as they seem

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
 well done bill...!... merle   Merle, It was of course the great surrealist René Magritte. Just credit my account with the 100 marks...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester wrote:  good one ...100 marks to those who know who the artist is merle   This is not a

[Zen] Re: red road

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Merle, Maybe the t'ai chi teacher has experience with zazen-styled seated meditation, and can set you up with a cushion to suit you, and suggest and model several postures which could suit you. Be sure that a cushion is not one of those hand-woven ones that you repeated write that you

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Siska, The premise is 'all SENTIENT beings have Buddha Nature', not just 'all beings'. 'Sentient' is very important because it is that quality that is Buddha Nature. How about I go to an outside source to address the uneasiness you've expressed in resolving how all have Buddha Nature but only

[Zen] Re: Tim Flach vs. Icecream; WAS: Tim Flach

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Merle, The image I saw scared me. It was late at night here, and I did not want to risk a possible nightmare or other upset. Maybe I'll try again some sunny day. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  huh..i am confused...don't you have virus protection on your computer?... pc i

[Zen] magaritte not duchamp joe

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
  Merle www.wix.com/merlewiitpom/1

Re: [Zen] Re: Tim Flach vs. Icecream; WAS: Tim Flach

2013-02-20 Thread Merle Lester
   god forbid..what would scare you joe?...merle   Merle, The image I saw scared me. It was late at night here, and I did not want to risk a possible nightmare or other upset. Maybe I'll try again some sunny day. --Joe Merle Lester wrote:  huh..i am confused...don't you have virus

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Siska, When we see any being as it is that is enlightenment (realization is my preferred word) whether that being is itself realized or not. Seeing oneself as unenlightened one must be unenlightened, at least partially. Seeing oneself as enlightened you could be fooling yourself, most likely

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Siska, I prefer to say we all ARE enlightened beings, but that some of us just don't realize that yet... We all live in the world of forms and all forms are illusions in the sense that they are not the individual things they seem to be but are actually empty information forms manifesting

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, Wrong! All beings and in fact everything that exists 'has Buddha Nature' because Buddha Nature (tao or ontological energy) is what everything in the universe is made out of... It is THE ONLY substance of reality because it is being or existence itself. Edgar On Feb 20, 2013, at 8:54

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Edgar, Bill!, All, I won't say yes, I won't say no. But just to note that... ...at the close of sesshin in the Diamond Sangha, there is a closing ceremony, and the Ino intones a Dedication (I've added my emphasis as all-caps, and preceding and leading stars): In the purity and clarity of the

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Edgar, I'm distressed and rather embarrassed to have to inform you on such a public forum as this that you have a teeny-weeny though not insignificant misunderstanding of what Buddha Nature is. You can read about it, write about it and think about it all you want but until you actually

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Plants, such as bushes and grasses, are sentient beings. Do you think otherwise? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Edgar, Bill!, All, I won't say yes, I won't say no. But just to note that... ...at the close of sesshin in the Diamond

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, I won't say. My point about hearing about them at the end of sesshin in this way is that it is just so welcome, and so unexpected (except after the first 45 or 50 sesshin attended), that it arouses laughter, in what has for seven solid days been (usually) a pretty solemn and silent

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, You sure always have a lot to say for someone who doesn't want to say a lot. I appreciate plants being sentient because it seems to me that they have senses and can experience. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Bill!, I won't say. My

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Mike, I say Edgar is right, though, that coming back is a hard part. Especially coming back from a long practice somewhere, and making your own (interruptable) schedule, again. It takes balance (retaining it, and, yes, reGaining it), and grace. Grace toward others and toward oneself.

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Maybe I missed something, but is your comment below addressed to Mike about Edgar's comment - and if so which one? Or should your comment below have been addressed to Edgar about Mike's comment - which you included below? Twirling in Thailand...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com,

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Hi, Bill!, Somewhere in the thread of posts of late regarding Buddha Nature, Edgar mentioned that a hard part in our practice is bringing our awakening to the realm of forms, and that meditation leading to awakening may have been the easy part of the old two-step. I didn't really think this

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread salik888
My meaning would be from teachers in Soto tradition who honor the Three Treasures -- Buddha, Dharma, Sangah . . . I would not care to comment about wiki /\ zendervish --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Zendervish, If you want to continue this discussion I'll

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, quoting Bill!: I appreciate plants being sentient because it seems to me that they have senses and can experience. Now how am I ever going to be able to look my potatoes in the eyes again? ;-) --Joe Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Joe, You sure always have a lot to say for someone

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Yes, I saw that. And also I too thought that although it was clumsily-worded his heart was in the right place. Or at least the form that we call his heart was in the right place. Or at least was I say it was in right place because I suspect any notion of Edgar actually having a heart

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, So...what does the term 'Dharma' mean to you? You use it as a word so you must have an idea of what it means. From your response I suspect it means 'Buddha's Teachings'. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, salik888 novelidea8@... wrote: My meaning would be from teachers

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Joe, Exactly! It gives the whole practice of being a vegetarian an entirely new meaning - hypocrite. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Bill!, quoting Bill!: I appreciate plants being sentient because it seems to me that they have senses and

[Zen] Re: Dogen, Mystical Realist

2013-02-20 Thread Bill!
Zendervish, I thought you'd choose #3. #1 is not illusion, but also it has nothing to do with laws, teachings or perceptions of phenomena. These are all illusory. As always a BIG - IN MY OPINION... ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, salik888 novelidea8@... wrote: Bill But we

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread Joe
Bill!, Now, now, not in the middle of that world. It's said that Mount Sumeru stands in the middle of that world. So, the heart may be displaced to one side of the Mountain... as it is in Humans to the left side of the medial line. And with that, a good night! --Joe PS (Quarter-inch of

Re: [Zen] Fw: peek a boo ...

2013-02-20 Thread uerusuboyo
Joe,br/br/I'm completely on board with you. Even on the micro-level (say after a few rounds of sitting zazen) you can feel the space between thoughts shrink if you don't keep up the intensity. But once thru the gateless gate there's a kind of 'muscle memory' that makes coming back to the mat