[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Joe
Bill!, quoting: I think Buddhism itself needs to be discarded completely. Face it: it cannot be. It is a living thing. Living things evolve. I see no asteroid coming to smack it. Zen practice is a personal choice for a person who can cut to the chase, ...or who can embrace nothing else.

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, LOL! Bill is the asteroid bent on destroying Buddhism! :-) Edgar On Jul 2, 2013, at 12:37 PM, Joe wrote: Bill!, quoting: I think Buddhism itself needs to be discarded completely. Face it: it cannot be. It is a living thing. Living things evolve. I see no asteroid coming to

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread uerusuboyo
br/Bill!,br/br/The Beatles were arguably the best band in the world and none of them could read music. Perhaps, therefore, we should discard with formal music notation?br/br/Mikebr/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Merle Lester
   mike.. how do you know this?...what is your evidence?.  i found that a bit far out.. who in the right mind would not want to know what all those musical notes meant?.. merle   Bill!, The Beatles were arguably the best band in the world and none of them could read music. Perhaps,

Fw: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Merle Lester
 why are you bringing this up as an argument joe..?..merle Remember the objection against considering to end the war in Vietnam?: What are you going to replace it with? joe .

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
I like that - KISS is our task now. I find the most Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Jul 2, 2013 2:49 AM, Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org wrote: Joe, I think Buddhism itself needs to be discarded completely. Zen, on the other hand, as it's presented in a lot of zen literature is presented

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/Sorry, I'm not sure what you're saying here? Evidence of what? And do you really think a symphony could be written without musical notation (never mind performed or taught!)?br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Fw: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Joe
Merle, Why? Just follow the thread. It's an outgrowth of my creativity. Not an apple or orange in the flow of it. You're a tough customer! And the customer is not always right, from at least some perspectives. That's why I mention following the thread. --Joe Merle Lester

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread Joe
Chris, Your signal is cutting out... . QSB, we say in radio. (fading) --Joe Chris Austin-Lane chris@... wrote: I like that - KISS is our task now. I find the most Thanks, --Chris Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you recently have

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-02 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!, Edgar,br/br/It's funny to hear you to argue that you think you both have a better way to the truth than the Buddhadharma. Goes to show what a formidable little critter the ego is. And to think you two both argue about its delusional nature! Lmfao! : )br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo!

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Suresh
You are correct Joe. Suresh --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Bill!, You might not be among the fortunate who lived 2500 years ago, when literacy was the exception. The skilful ways of the ancestors might be hard for an English-Major to comprehend!

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Edgar Owen
@...; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage Sent: Sun, Jun 30, 2013 12:40:13 AM Mike, Yes, you are right. I mistook Buddha Dharma for Buddha Nature which is another name for my ontological energy

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, I agree with this in general.. Edgar On Jun 30, 2013, at 10:45 PM, Bill! wrote: Joe, Most religions are wisdom traditions. Their core beliefs may indeed be just as pertinent today as they were 2500 years ago. It's not their core beliefs I'm uncomfortable with, it's their method

Re: [Zen] Re: Social responsibility

2013-07-01 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill and Suresh, One person's social responsibility is another person's fun... Edgar On Jul 1, 2013, at 1:08 AM, Bill! wrote: Suresh, Nice story, but I think it's not just Indian people that show no 'social responsibility'. I'm sure everyone of us on this Forum see acts like this

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Joe
Edgar, Wisdom is carried, through the work of the traditions. They are vessels, vehicles, and delivery-systems of methods, techniques. It's the teaching ways of the traditions that changes, nimbly, to suit the time and place. I think little basis changes. That is my view! No one but a

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Joe
Bill!, No, every generation makes some changes in how they teach, live, and in the records they write down, or that others write about them. I just found it odd that you should take the Buddha to task for beginning the teaching in his day of an entirely new system with a simple outline,

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Joe
Bill!, Every generation has a responsibility to the present and the future. I suspect you personally are doing the updating that you can. Onward! It's said that Buddhism passes from one warm hand to another. It's not that this needs updating; it's always changing, anyway. Joe Campbell

[Zen] Re: Intellectualizing -

2013-07-01 Thread Joe
Yes, Bill! quoting: As soon as you see something, you already start to intellectualize it. As soon as you intellectualize something, it is no longer what you saw. Now, what about when that's not so? The out-of-context line is too glaringly black and white. What about when you see something,

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Your saying that No one but a practitioner in a tradition can say that the tradition no longer has the best truth. is nonsense. All kinds of nutcase cult followers would claim their tradition is the best and only truth and that all the other ones didn't. There are objective standards of

[Zen] Re: Intellectualizing -

2013-07-01 Thread pudgala2
As soon as you see something, The unenlightened only see what their preconditioned constituent sentient beings (beliefs, attitudes, opinions, moods, values, etc.) will allow or force them to see and nothing more, you already start to intellectualize it. sentient beings automatically process it.

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-07-01 Thread Joe
Edgar, I think when Buddha first taught, people thought he might just be an eccentric. And look at the traipsings of the traditionally playful Hotei. So I agree there may be a fine line, here. In the main, I still defer to practitioners, and not to outside judges, ...who practice something

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Mike, The Noble Eightfold Path is a good guideline. So are the Ten Commandments. I have three problems with the Noble Eightfold Path: 1. There are 8 categories. Why are all the activities that are possible in life divided into 8 categories? Do the authors of this really think those 8

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/1) Actually, the Noble Eightfold Path (NEP) is divided into 3 categories: br/br/Ethical Conduct: (right speech; right livelihood)br/Mental Development: (right effort; right mindfulness; right concentration)br/Wisdom: (right intention; right view)br/br/2) On What is Rightbr/br/Right

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Mike, Thanks for your explanation and references. I agree that the Zen Patriarchs were well-schooled in the sutras. Whether that knowledge helped them awaken I do not know. Personally I think things like these help you become interested in awakening and perhaps even give you strength and

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Edgar Owen
@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage Sent: Sun, Jun 30, 2013 12:40:13 AM Mike, Yes, you are right. I mistook Buddha Dharma for Buddha Nature which is another name for my ontological energy. As to the volume of work produced my book

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, Agreed with one addition. Right action does help decrease suffering which in turn makes it easier to attain realization. Of course with realization one naturally follows the 8 fold path which as you point out is somewhat arbitrary... Edgar On Jun 30, 2013, at 6:00 AM, Bill! wrote:

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
NEP? Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Jun 30, 2013 8:01 AM, Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net wrote: Bill, Agreed with one addition. Right action does help decrease suffering which in turn makes it easier to attain realization. Of course with realization one naturally follows the 8 fold path

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/The only thing I would say in response is that the Buddha Dharma is far more that just a tool to motivate, but is actually a path that can take you to the other shore ( I know, I know! There is no other shore ; )br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/Well, that's at least one then! : )br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/Not sure what you mean by right action. Yes, if you come at it from an already awakened position then you would just be following the Noble Eightfold Path. But if this is so, then following the path will also lead to awakening. I would also say that there is nothing arbitrary about

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread 覺妙精明 (JMJM)
that can take you to the other shore ( I know, I know! There is no other shore ; ) Mike Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad *From: * Bill! billsm...@hhs1963.org; *To: * Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; *Subject: * [Zen] Re: Fw

[Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
the hell are you in a cell working on escape plans?! On Fri, 6/28/13, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Subject: [Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, June 28, 2013, 9:10 PM PBS, I think it's

[Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Mike, Thank you!! For my penance surviving another year as a rice-bag, I ran a quarter-marathon. Before it got hot, out. To keep this further on topic, let me say that the weather and climate are an inspiration to my art, which is a part of my Practice / Sadhana. Paintings. And

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Edgar, Bill!, Group, Counting and recitation were part of the oral tradition, leading toward transmission of the material and its memorization, as in Bradbury's, FAHRENHEIT 451 (Celcius 233). It has real historical roots, not obsessional. You may look into it. Moderns think they're not

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Chris, You've got it. No speculation, though. That's *exactly* why certain objects in the teachings were numbered. That practice has a long history in India before Shakyamuni lived. Humans are pretty neat, in our capabilities, when it comes to important things. Especially having to do

[Zen] Re: A TERRIFYING LOOK AT THE CONTROL OF WEATHER WARFARE

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Mr. Suresh, Again I caution that Mr. Begich is a bit of an alarmist; he may be passing dis-information, besides. A headline with Terrifying in it should be taken calmly, I think. It's propaganda. Energy expenditures to do what is claimed -- or hoped! -- in the article would be enormous.

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Bill!, You might not be among the fortunate who lived 2500 years ago, when literacy was the exception. The skilful ways of the ancestors might be hard for an English-Major to comprehend! Breadth-Requirements might have had a chance of filling you in on the facts. No? All but forgotten? I

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Mike, I agree, sir. Religions are Wisdom-Traditions. Wisdom Traditions use the tools they have available. Then, and now. That, too, is what makes them Wise. They utilize fully what they have available, in service of True Compassion. For their times, and future times. Religions are not

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Mike, Buddha's Flower Sermon evidently spoke *volumes*. And obviated them. Kudos! Hard to touch that. Mahakasyapa was the first generation beyond Buddha, if not co-generational in years, then, in Lineage. Maybe we count the Buddha as zero, and, ...I hope so. He might, too. But I won't

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Joe
Mike, quoting: ( I know, I know! There is no other shore ; ) Shore, shore. --Joe uerusuboyo@... wrote: Bill!, The only thing I would say in response is that the Buddha Dharma is far more that just a tool to motivate, but is actually a path that can take you to the other shore ( I know,

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, First you say that ancient traditions as they were are to be respected. Then you say they are constantly changing implying they are different now. These are two clearly contradictory views. So which is it in your view? Actually I have a different take on it but which is largely in

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
@... wrote: Edgar, No worries. Btw, Buddha would've been an Apple user. Mike Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad From: Edgar Owen edgarowen@...; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage Sent: Sun, Jun 30, 2013 12:40:13 AM

[Zen] Re: Zen_Forum Posting Practices

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Pudgala2, If this is your contribution to the 'potluck' I'd like to have a 2nd and 3rd and 4th, etc... helping please... ;) ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, pudgala2 pudgala2@... wrote: Hello to All Members of Zen_Forum, Posting my understanding of Zen on Buddhist forums

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Joe, So are you saying that we should not make any attempts to modernize and make more relevant the mode of explanations and teachings from that of 2500 years ago? If that were the case in your line of work (astronomy) wouldn't we still be locked into the earth as being flat and the center of

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Joe, Most religions are wisdom traditions. Their core beliefs may indeed be just as pertinent today as they were 2500 years ago. It's not their core beliefs I'm uncomfortable with, it's their method of communicating their core beliefs - their myths, parables and symbols. It's these I'd like

[Zen] Re: Social responsibility

2013-06-30 Thread Bill!
Suresh, Nice story, but I think it's not just Indian people that show no 'social responsibility'. I'm sure everyone of us on this Forum see acts like this every day in every part of the world. From a zen perspective I would say this is just a lack of compassion. These people are two

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Bill!
Edgar, As you know I don't like to rely too much on Buddhist or Hindu terms either. 'Samadhi' is a meditative state of non-duality or monism. It's what I also call 'shikantazaza' if you're experiencing it during zazen. It can also be called no-thought. I associate it strongly with Buddha

RE: [Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption

2013-06-29 Thread uerusuboyo
Joe,br/br/Happy Birthday, geezer!br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, I think it's a matter of definition. In general I think excessive concern with 'stages' of realization is a distraction from realization... And that goes for standard Buddhism's obsessive with counting all sorts of things as well. The 7 this, the 5 that, the 8 this etc. etc. Edgar

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
Don't forget the eightfold way. I have heard it speculated that numbered lists make it easier in an oral tradition to remember stuff, and that the proliferation of numbered items in ancient spiritual traditions, especial Buddhism, are a normal result of a few hundred years of oral transmission.

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Edgar Owen
Chris, Yes, that could well be... Edgar On Jun 29, 2013, at 7:31 AM, Chris Austin-Lane wrote: Don't forget the eightfold way. I have heard it speculated that numbered lists make it easier in an oral tradition to remember stuff, and that the proliferation of numbered items in ancient

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Bill!
Edgar, I agree 100% with that! Like the Noble Eightfold Path: Right Speech, Right Thought, Right Intentions, etc... Why do they name only 8 classes? Why do they name classes at all? Why not just: Live Right? And anyway the challenge isn't doing all the 'right' things. The challenge is

[Zen] Re: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread SURESH JAGADEESAN
Dear Sri.Rajaram, “You never replied in those incidents how did you feel in those days, It happened in Ariyalur, sabarimala, Godavari boat, sri lanka, Somalia, Saudi Kabba, Chennai to KK beach and Indonasia etc tsunami.” Of course, first scared, worried, since I put my self in those situations

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, Yes, I suspect it was just all those monks got so terribly bored with the monastic life doing the same boring routine all day every day for their whole lives they desperately needed something to occupy their minds. Can you imagine a life of continually counting your prayer beads over and

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/I can tell by the completely misrepresented view of things like The Noble Eightfold Path on this forum that people criticise even though it's obvious they haven't even bothered to study them. They're absolutely beautiful and sublime teachings. Even though they're over 2,500 years

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/The Buddhadharma in its present form has been around for 2,500 years and still applicable today. I wonder how long your ontological energy theory (or whatever it is) will be around?...br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Edgar Owen
Mike, It's two names for the same thing, though understood differently by many of course... It's not the names that matter since the thing itself is nameless. It's the thing itself that matters... I wouldn't get hung up in the names for it Edgar On Jun 29, 2013, at 10:57 AM,

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/They're not the same thing with a different name. 'Buddha Dharma' refers to the whole body of work developed and taught by the Buddha including the sutras and methods of meditation etc. I've yet to see anything resembling this from you (seeing illusion as reality doesn't really

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread Edgar Owen
to see anything resembling this from you (seeing illusion as reality doesn't really comprise a whole body of work). Mike Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad From: Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-29 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/No worries. Btw, Buddha would've been an Apple user.br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

RE: [Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-28 Thread uerusuboyo
Joe,br/br/What? Are you saying I couldn't be a Zen master? I'll have you know I read a book on Zen once. Well, ok - it was a pamphlet about the temple I was visiting. But it was very informative pamphlet. With pictures and all.br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

[Zen] Re: GOD (Generator, Organizer Destroyer).

2013-06-28 Thread SURESH JAGADEESAN
Dear Sir, We are in very sorry state. Nothing can help us. We are ruining, our days are counted. I also looking out for god to help us. If he is there I am very much happy. Why not look beyond Mahaperiva? Living in cage(prison) and not realised that your living in your own prison You will say

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/There is no confusion in what I said at all and it also depends on from which tradition you're talking about karma. As I've been taught, karma will indeed play itself out, but only as long as a person still identifies themselves with a self. Upon awakening to our Original Nature

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Bill!
Edgar, Mike, Suresh, et al... I think this is just the same old conundrum associated with Dependent Arising vs. Independent Existence (Buddhism) and Predestination vs. Free Will (Christian). I'm staying out of this discussion for the most part because as most of you know already I think

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Suresh
Dear Joe, Thanks for the reply. I will read about Yogacara Buddhist philosophy. Then come back to you. Brgds Suresh --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe desert_woodworker@... wrote: Suresh, Your approach seems good, and practical. I suppose there is a large weight of comfort in

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Mike, First, the law of karma is nonsense. I'm not defending it, just explaining it. Also as you can see your reply as received was garbled so don't have time to wade through it all.. Yes, karma plays itself out eventually. As to karma suddenly ceasing that's only when all forms cease in what

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/You're certainly entitled to your opinion that karma is nonsense, but I agree with the Buddhadharma - that on observing the natural world there are laws that affect it. These laws govern the universe and as we are part of the universe those same laws govern us. Whether you see them

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
. Mike Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad From: Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage Sent: Fri, Jun 28, 2013 11:40:32 AM Mike, First, the law of karma is nonsense. I'm not defending it, just

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Bill!
Edgar, I liked your description of the difference between enlightenment and nirvana: ...enlightenment in which one does not leave the world of forms but just sees them for what they truly are... and In nirvana all forms cease permanently. I agree with that and use the term 'delusions' as a

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Bill!
Edgar, As a follow-on to this, what do you consider the difference/distinction between samadhi and nirvana? ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Bill! BillSmart@... wrote: Edgar, I liked your description of the difference between enlightenment and nirvana: ...enlightenment in

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread uerusuboyo
Edgar,br/br/There really is no confusion in my post whatsoever. Buddha wanted to find out how to live happily and at peace in an ever changing world. His first premise was that from the actual you can deduce the practical. The actual are the laws I mentioned previously. His second premise was

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Edgar, On a point of order, I don't think it's appropriate here -- now -- or ever -- to use the word crazy when referring to a religion. Such loose talk is the cause of trouble. You may have (and maintain) your biases, of course, but you are not helpful to the conversation and to relations,

[Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Mike, I'm just not qualified to nominate you as a Zen master. I am an un-transmitted Dharma Teacher in Sheng Yen's line, and still in training the next few years in USA and Taiwan in the details of running Ch'an retreat (Sesshin), and teaching to students. I feel qualified to urge you and

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, OK, then the only disagreement is that I maintain your 'delusions' are PART of reality since I define reality as everything that exists without exception and you think delusions are NOT part of reality... Without that additional step you don't realize the meaning of 'mountains are

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Dear Suresh, Yogacara is also referred to as the Consciousness-Only School, and sometimes as Mind-Only. It is based on the Eight Consciousnesses. Yogacara is still alive, but it has been absorbed into other Schools, either entirely, or just in bits and pieces. Zen Buddhism has absorbed some.

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, I don't use the term and don't really get into all the interminable Buddhist and HIndu levels and counts of everything anyone could think of... Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 10:13 AM, Bill! wrote: Edgar, As a follow-on to this, what do you consider the difference/distinction between

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
: Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage Sent: Fri, Jun 28, 2013 1:29:08 PM Mike, You are confusing cause and effect which is obviously true (even though Bill denies it) and karma which is a pre

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, All religions are CRAZY. They are delusional nonsense long refuted by science. Zen is revealing the truth about everything. It's not coddling organized religion but pointing out it's an impediment to realization.. Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 10:18 AM, Joe wrote: Edgar, On a point of

[Zen] Re: A TERRIFYING LOOK AT THE CONTROL OF WEATHER WARFARE

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Suresh, - CAUTION -- OFF-ZEN-TOPIC REPLY, and FACTUAL DATA-DUMP - Mr. Begich is a bit of an alarmist, and has been so on this matter for two decades. I think there is a large bit of hoaxing involved. Also, glaringly, the figure quoted for the power radiated by the antenna array is

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Edgar, Bill!, This does not seem appropriate speech, here, considering all we've gone through to establish civility and maintain rules of conduct. As certain doctrines are central to certain traditions, it is NOT appropriate to call them names, when one views from a set of biases which have

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Bill!, Will you please moderate this fellow? His continued blatant assertions are offensive and inappropriate in a civil forum. w/ thanks!, --Joe Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, All religions are CRAZY. They are delusional nonsense long refuted by science. Zen is revealing the

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread 覺妙精明 (JMJM)
! Mail for iPad *From: * Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net; *To: * Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; *Subject: * Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage *Sent: * Thu, Jun 27, 2013 1:07:05 PM Mike, No, this is not the correct

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Civility applies to persons on the list, not abstract doctrines many of which, especially those of the organized religions are total delusional nonsense and should be outed as such... Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 11:20 AM, Joe wrote: Edgar, Bill!, This does not seem appropriate

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
PS: I doubt Jesus' feelings will be hurt by anything I say about the religion founded in his name that has little to do with him since he's been dead for some 2000 years. But if he was alive I suspect he'd be agreeing with me rather than Joe... Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 12:00 PM, Edgar

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Edgar, (and Bill!), Pls. be advised of the POSSIBILITY that persons on the list -- maybe many of them quiet -- may hold doctrines dearly, personally, and importantly. It is not your place to call the doctrines, or those who hold them, names. Doctrines and practices are held by PEOPLE: they

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Mike, I think you indeed do well to distinguish that there are various and varying conceptions and operational views of karma in different (Wisdom-) traditions, Conceptions and views differ also in the different sects, and sub-sects, of traditions. Simply, karma originally means action, not

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Stop your carping and reread the rules... Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 12:09 PM, Joe wrote: Edgar, (and Bill!), Pls. be advised of the POSSIBILITY that persons on the list -- maybe many of them quiet -- may hold doctrines dearly, personally, and importantly. It is not your place

Re: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Stop your carping and reread the rules... The moderators have agreed on the rules and it's not up to you to change them. A single complaint is OK, but incessant gripping on the same issue is off topic and has nothing to do with zen.. Edgar On Jun 28, 2013, at 12:09 PM, Joe wrote:

Re: [Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-28 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Changing a thread title is fine and is encouraged when the poster wants to transition to a new thread. Nothing wrong with it at all. On the other hand snipping does destroy the integrity of threads and is deprecated. You are the only poster here that does it. That being said I don't

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Edgar, Take the same advice. Your insults are beyond the pale, especially for a presumed moderator. See Chris' Posting Tips, as well. I give this advice as a friendly suggestion, and for the benefit of all here concerned. tnx, --Joe Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, Stop your

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
It has to do with the rules, broken on two different occasions by a presumed moderator in the same day, hence the two complaints. Come, now; if we're on to a new way of operating, surely you are most welcome to fall in line, also. Leave behind the nasties and gutter tactics, and pls. discuss

[Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Edgar, Just don't incur the need for it, and post civilly. Problem solved! We'll let it go at that. --Joe Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, Changing a thread title is fine and is encouraged when the poster wants to transition to a new thread. Nothing wrong with it at all. On the

[Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
PBS, I think it's right. It depends on what one escapes into, and maybe even on how, and why. Or if escape is the truth of the matter. Any other pointers, perfume advisories, or menu recommendations? I'm having my birthday cake in 30 minutes. Be free, healthy, in the Dharma, --Joe

[Zen] Re: WAS BUDDHA AN AVATHAARA OF VISHNU ?:

2013-06-28 Thread Joe
Dear Mr. Suresh, It is wonderful. TOO wonderful for me. I think, too, that you out-do yourself, there. It is truly FINE. Do others think so, too? Wow! Glad to know you. Maybe the only thing to do next is to use a ploy or tactic they will *NOT* expect. Try a perspective from Zen. It's

Re: [Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption

2013-06-28 Thread pandabananasock
...@yahoo.com wrote: Subject: [Zen] Re: The Samsarashank Redemption To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Date: Friday, June 28, 2013, 9:10 PM PBS, I think it's right. It depends on what one escapes into, and maybe even on how, and why.  Or if escape is the truth of the matter. Any other

[Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-27 Thread Suresh
Dear Joe, I understand your concern. The members of other forum describe that catastrophe as order of god or fate or Karma. I oppose as it is nothing to do with god, fate or Karma, it is science's cause and effect such as global warming and inadequate disaster management in the country and

[Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-27 Thread Bill!
Mike, There are two of us so we will moderate ourselves. We will also listen to any complaints or suggestions any of you have. Also, if anyone wants to volunteer to be a Moderator please let us know. Neither Edgar or I intend to be Moderator here for life. ...Bill! --- In

[Zen] Re: moderation

2013-06-27 Thread Bill!
JMJM, Interesting suggestion. I guess it's the new e-version of 'The Scarlet Letter'. I'm not sure what 'tagging' is or how to do it, but I will discuss this with Edgar and let everyone know our decision. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, 覺妙精明 (JMJM) chan.jmjm@... wrote:

RE: [Zen] Re: Posting and Replying Policy - Draft

2013-06-27 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/Fair enough. I assume you'll both be holding each other to the same standard expected of the rest of us..br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

RE: [Zen] Re: Fw: It was like Shiva dancing in rage

2013-06-27 Thread uerusuboyo
Suresh,br/br/Hope you don't mind me jumping in here? Someone has the wrong understanding of karma. At least the karma a taught by Buddha. Karma is not the same as a fatalistic or determinative belief. Karma can be changed at anytime if the right actions/thoughts are performed. Also, it is wrong

<    1   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   >