Re: [Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, You are totally uninformed. The amount of bandwidth you save by snipping a few words of text is absolutely inconsequential. You could I guess look it up but of course you think facts are incompatible with Zen.. Edgar On Jun 11, 2013, at 4:58 PM, Joe wrote: Merle, Merle is a

Re: [Zen] Re: the teaching

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 joe..you harp and you harp about the teacher...i harp back...the greatest teacher is yourself! merle   Merle, Artists, yes. Maybe one in two is self-taught, despite all teachers's exertions. But in Zen, it is different. Ours is a Human endeavor. More Human than Art. You, Merle, only

Re: [Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 joe likes to snip... snip and more snipping...it is his trademark..the snipper...merle   Joe, You are totally uninformed. The amount of bandwidth you save by snipping a few words of text is absolutely inconsequential.  You could I guess look it up but of course you think facts are

Re: [Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 spare a dime and save a dollar... are you by any chance.. what i refer to as a tight arse... ? merle   Edgar, It's the phone guys I hope to spare! --Joe Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, You are totally uninformed. The amount of bandwidth you save by snipping a few words of

[Zen] Re: the teaching

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, I do no harping. I just say that in the Zen Sect, a teacher is necessary. Granted, it may seem a funny thing. But when you have a teacher, let me hear from you. We can compare smiles. And, if you can still find a yourself, then less power to you! --J. Merle Lester merlewiitpom@...

Re: [Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 re- phasing ...the word is skinflint..as opposed to tight arse... you can't take it with you...jesus said  the rich man will not make it through the  eye of a needle...merle  spare a dime and save a dollar... are you by any chance.. what i refer to as a tight arse... ? merle   Edgar,

Re: [Zen] Re: the teaching

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 joe...for the hundredth time..i live 75 ks from sydney..it's not happening... be kind...merle   Merle, I do no harping. I just say that in the Zen Sect, a teacher is necessary. Granted, it may seem a funny thing. But when you have a teacher, let me hear from you. We can compare smiles.

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, I don't like it. I miss(ed) the liking of it. It's just that I know nothing of emailers' prejudices, and weaknesses. Or, of WHY you should care if a few characters that I do not reply to are missing. You have a lot to account for, there, but I will not hold you to account. There.

Re: [Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Merle Lester
 joe..it is an observation not a criticism... merle   Merle, I don't like it. I miss(ed) the liking of it. It's just that I know nothing of emailers' prejudices, and weaknesses. Or, of WHY you should care if a few characters that I do not reply to are missing. You have a lot to account

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, I won't say. But Bob and Charles both resigned from this Group, most lately; I think cost was not immaterial. Weren't they both cell-phone emailers? Chris, too, should be spared excessive repetition of drivel, etc. Not to mention other rich guys, here. Best Rgds, --Joe Merle

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, I care not to incur costs for others. Those costs are not my costs. I will not harm others, willy-nilly. You? -J. Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: re- phasing ...the word is skinflint..as opposed to tight arse... you can't take it with you...jesus said the rich man will not

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, Critical observation. But I do not care. Cousins are cousins. You know I care to keep cell-phone members in the Black. Not Red. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: joe..it is an observation not a criticism... merle Current Book

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Merle, If you can follow it, here you go: Scarlet Begonias. I've posted it before. I was in town that night, but not at the concert hall. Sweetie and I were in Central Park, under the fireworks. This is a piece of the Dead's Dec. 31, 1978 concert, in my town. Try:

[Zen] Re: past life

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
And, Merle: Here is my cousin Buckethead, with his fine Beware the Holding Funnel. Who knows what it means. But, beware!: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kWX-DXekL3U -- Joe --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: joe..it is an observation not a criticism...

Re: [Zen] Re: the teaching

2013-06-11 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Zen is not a sect. That's an enormous misunderstanding of what Zen is and I'm sure even Bill would agree.. Zen is realizing the true nature of reality. It has nothing to do with sects, gurus or their ilks... Edgar On Jun 11, 2013, at 8:59 PM, Joe wrote: Merle, I do no harping.

[Zen] Re: the teaching

2013-06-11 Thread Joe
Edgar, Sect of Buddhism. Don't give the Religion no grief, m'man. Others divorce the baby from the bathwater. That may be OK. I haven't tested it. Bill! does OK, evidently. As for me, I won't say. It's immaterial. Sect is a good word. I use it, lovingly. I do not misunderstand. Not

Re: [Zen] Re: Another Cartoon - But This Time Not Zen-Related

2013-06-10 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, And Genghis Khan butchered people by the thousands... -- but it was totally OK because he made thousands more by impregnating thousands of women... :-) Edgar On Jun 9, 2013, at 10:09 PM, Joe wrote: Bill!, Fine enough. But trees have always been Friends. My ex- also used to

[Zen] Re: Another Cartoon - But This Time Not Zen-Related

2013-06-10 Thread Bill!
Edgar, Okay...this was a good one...I'll give you credit for that... ;) --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, And Genghis Khan butchered people by the thousands... -- but it was totally OK because he made thousands more by impregnating thousands of

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-10 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, There is only one answer or solution to ALL koans. And that is Buddha Nature. So all one has to do in response to any koan is simply to point to anything at all and convincingly bring attention to its Buddha Nature. But as I say repeatedly anything at all can be a koan to get you to that

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-10 Thread Merle Lester
hippy hippy shake..joe..merle   Mike, Merle, A shedding of dirty clothes, the Old Man used to say; even down to your socks. He talked about awakening as being nakedness. Having nothing. Wu (Chin.). Mu (Japanese). How true. But, no embarrassment! This is original Human nakedness.

Re: [Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread Merle Lester
 ok..that's fine..however according to some experts some of us are hard wired to believe in god.. i maybe one of those..so what choice does one have..and god is god is god.. merle   Merle, Which god? The Christian one? Zeus? Allah? Krishna? Odin? Even if you pinpoint which god (The Big

Re: [Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/A belief in a god could well be beneficial and even advantageous for evolutionary survival, but that still doesn't make it true.br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-09 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle, br/br/I think you might need a certain amount of faith when you first read this, but only if you haven't experienced it. What you'll find from a diligent practice of meditation is that awakening is a process of stripping down (losing attachments, dropping ideas and concepts of 'self'

[Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread Bill!
Merle, Saying some of us are hard wired to believe in god might be true, but I think it would be better stated that 'we all as humans are wired insufficiently to understand everything we perceive' (with the possible exception of Edgar). IMO what we tend to do is make up explanations for

RE: [Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/Great explanation!br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-09 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, The point of my reply to your post both of which you obsessively snipped is this Your post went against even the view of koans you are supposed to believe in as an orthodox zennist. You and Bill claim that koans have no solution but are to be discarded in a satori. But instead your post

Re: [Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, Get your Gods straight. It was Helios or Apollo, depending on the culture, who drove the chariot of the sun across the sky, not Mercury... Jeez, no wonder you can't understand Zen! :-) Edgar On Jun 9, 2013, at 6:56 AM, Bill! wrote: Merle, Saying some of us are hard wired to

[Zen] Re: does edgar agree?

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Merle, That would be immaterial; but, go ahead and see; I don't mind. You pay attention for both of us -- you and me!, i.e. -- please. On this score, there is no doubt anywhere, ...and it's a big universe. See if Bill! agrees, and Mike, and Chris. And Subhana, Roshi. And John Tarrant Roshi.

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Chris, Don't confuse crazy with compassionate! ;-) I know you don't. I've gotten swift swats from Sheng Yen on occasion, in Interview (dokusan). Sometimes to compliment, and sometimes to chastise, but usually to encourage. You know how it goes. Or I hope so. Especially with a teacher

[Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Merle, There is no wiring. Don't believe a word of that hooey/horse-hockey. If you awaken, you may find that beliefs and illusions have all dropped. Where are they? They are gone. Like a clear sky. What there is, instead, is a hearty participation in Life, WITH all of Life. There's no

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Mike, Merle, A shedding of dirty clothes, the Old Man used to say; even down to your socks. He talked about awakening as being nakedness. Having nothing. Wu (Chin.). Mu (Japanese). How true. But, no embarrassment! This is original Human nakedness. Our original inheritance. And, no one

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Edgar, If YOU take things literally, then that's what YOU do. Anyone who passes the koan What is the sound of One Hand?, makes a demonstration. It's easy, at that time. After that work. What are you all hung up about? Edgar, note, too: my practice has been not too much on koans; after a

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-09 Thread Bill!
Edgar, I agree with Joe here. All the 'breakthrough' koans (the first ones that are specifically designed to induce kensho (first experience of Buddha Nature)require a demonstration rather than an explanation. For example my first koan was Joshu's MU and my teacher's request was to BRING me

[Zen] Re: Another Cartoon - But This Time Not Zen-Related

2013-06-09 Thread Joe
Bill!, Fine enough. But trees have always been Friends. My ex- also used to sleep up in trees when she was a child. Remarkable: it could have gone badly! Even though I butcher trees to make things for Buddhist temples and teachers, I have trees as friends, everywhere. North and South. But

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread Merle Lester
   joe..rubbish he went to india... he was 36 was he not when he was crucified?.. you should know all his life story as you were once a catholic..  what the hell do you mean by no mind?..no mind then you would be brain dead...  it's not reinventing the wheel.. it's evolution... who wants to

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread Bill!
Merle, I'll stay out of the discussions about Jesus' itineraries, but I THINK my 'One Mind' Joe means what I mean when I say 'integration of Buddha Nature and the Human Intellect, and by 'No Mind' Joe means just Buddha Nature... ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle!!br/br/I know very little about Christianity, but even I've heard that there is very little known about his life from the age of 12 to when he entered Jerusalem. The Silk Route was a well travelled journey by many at that time is there is reasonable speculation he 'may' have gone

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Edgar Owen
Bill, O boy, here we go again Maybe YOUR intellect shuts down but my intellect IS Buddha Nature Edgar On Jun 7, 2013, at 11:17 PM, Bill! wrote: Suresh, et al... I agree with Joe here. In fact zen koans are used to exhaust logic and dialectic. When you try to use logic or

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
I didn't think you had done Koan training, Edgar? Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Jun 8, 2013 4:40 AM, Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net wrote: Bill, O boy, here we go again Maybe YOUR intellect shuts down but my intellect IS Buddha Nature Edgar On Jun 7, 2013, at 11:17 PM,

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
Ok, but would you agree that Bill's descrion of classical koan training is accurate - the koan is used to silence the generation of thoughts and words? Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 On Jun 8, 2013 6:47 AM, Edgar Owen edgaro...@att.net wrote: Chris, I've been dealing with the quantum koan

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Edgar Owen
Chris, That's the theory, but it's only one of several types of first steps for beginners to (hopefully) get a little satori experience by temporarily exhausting their brains trying to figure out something that doesn't have an easy solution. The other approach is to actually SOLVE the koan

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Edgar Owen
Chris and Bill, Example of the solution of a koan. What's the sound of one hand clapping? The solution is the recognition that language is capable of expressing irrational meaningless syntax. Therefore language itself isn't truth unless what it expresses is consistent with the overall

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread Joe
Merle, See?, even the basic murmurings of the Zen sect, you are unaware of. Why does it all come as a surprise to you, after so long a time? The Zen you've been looking into for decades rings pretty hollow. There is no mind. What you call mind is your SENSATION of illusions. When we are

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Joe
Edgar, Bill!, Chris, Group, The actual (real) koan reads: What is the sound of one hand? The clapping is not original, and is incorrect to insert. Not only incorrect, but misleading. It's a 1950's bit of b.s. appended by some American or English illiterate non-practitioner. The koan has

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Edgar Owen
Joe, Bah! Humbug! Edgar On Jun 8, 2013, at 5:46 PM, Joe wrote: Edgar, Bill!, Chris, Group, The actual (real) koan reads: What is the sound of one hand? The clapping is not original, and is incorrect to insert. Not only incorrect, but misleading. It's a 1950's bit of b.s. appended

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
I was going to say that in all my conversations with people studying koans and all my reading of zen, I have never before run into a claim of solving a koan. However, in fact, there is a book called After Zen about a Dutch detective who becomes disillusioned with Zen (Rinzai school, as practised

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Joe
Edgar, Well, that's IT (that DOES it). You are OFF my Christmas Card list! ;-) Humbug right back, Your'n truly, -- Hose-B Edgar Owen edgarowen@... wrote: Joe, Bah! Humbug! Edgar Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you recently have

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Joe
Chris, Anger is bound to get a student a swift swat with an agile stick. That's why I make my sticks as I do: agile; swift; flexible; noisy; durable. Of quarter-sawn timber. Sometimes plain-sawn. I make them to last several lifetimes, but a teacher usually only exercises them for a single

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread Merle Lester
 joe...why are you picking on me...how do you know i was not testing you?..i can see you get worked up into a sweat..when really your answer would have been more simple..you tell me i now know nothing about zen..so...how do you really know what i have ben looking for?...do you know for sure

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-08 Thread Joe
Merle, Don't bother continuing this. Continue with your Practice. See a Teacher as you are able. Everything depends on that. --Joe PS I pick on you because you are my Cousin, Cousin. Because you did not know that No-Mind is the hallmark of realized Zennists. That is inexcusable, ...to

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-08 Thread Chris Austin-Lane
I've never heard you describe your lineage as crazy, Joe. My practise at the moment - reading a Percy Jackson book to a very tired 8.5 year old who is fighting the bed time ritual with upset and so on. Q Thanks, --Chris 301-270-6524 Chris, Anger is bound to get a student a swift swat with an

[Zen] Re: Karma..many thanks

2013-06-08 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/Which god? The Christian one? Zeus? Allah? Krishna? Odin? Even if you pinpoint which god (The Big Daddy Creator) there is absolutely no evidence to believe in him or even make him necessary. I see, feel, smell, taste and hear reality. Take away the I and what more do you

[Zen] Re: a puppet on a string

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, You always think people are talking about YOU. Where does that come from? Now, answer me: do you think companies are wasting shareholders' money by advertizing? --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: joe..the awakened human has no time for advertising unless it create a good

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, If you are asking about the general you, then here is the procedure: you consult your teacher, or a teacher. A teacher knows all the signs, and cannot be fooled. A teacher can also tell you how to proceed, to deepen and take care of your realization. It is a long-term process. A Zen

Re: [Zen] Re: a puppet on a string

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 well joe..as i have stated before there is no i therefore there is no you!!..there is only ONE  advertising is over the top.. anyone with any nuance would realise this..  does not take blind freddie to open the curtains and see   yes it is all a waste  and ONE does not need the nonsense

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
  i see joe...  is that what YOU were taught?..the wine- cellar scenario?  there are teachers and teachers... and more teachers.. again i ask who is the teacher and who is the student?  did not many a musical genius start his career in the basement to climb to the top of the dizzy heights?

[Zen] Re: little white lies

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, You take me 180 degrees WRONG. I said that we don't need hospitals and drug interactions to teach us about our practice, or to teach us, say, metaphysics. Suresh is looking to out-of-body experiences of the critically-ill for insight about the mind. I wrote that this is not

Fw: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, Contemplation dispels it. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  joe..well well well..no soul ... is it too frightening to contemplate?..merle Merle, That's correct. But someone who is *NOT* a follower of the Buddha (i.e., NOT a Buddhist) who believes in a soul may

[Zen] Re: a puppet on a string

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, Cause and effect applies to people, all people. No matter if awakened or not. There is no escape from dependent arising, dependent origination. Several famous koans treat this, and lots of good Buddhist philosophy. A practitioner will also see it demonstrated in his/her own life and

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Dear Merle, Our practice does not result in an acquirement. It results in a loss. When we lose all, we are in the basement. We are below the foundation of all things. It's a good place. It is the ground of our Humanity, and of all beings, and all things. There is nothing dizzying (nor

Re: [Zen] Re: little white lies

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
  joe...maybe a mis read ..however there is never an opportunity missed..even in hospital to reach enlightenment..even if it's on the operating table!..merle   Merle, You take me 180 degrees WRONG. I said that we don't need hospitals and drug interactions to teach us about our practice,

Re: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 why joe..why dispel soul?..merle   Merle, Contemplation dispels it. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  joe..well well well..no soul ... is it too frightening to contemplate?..merle Merle, That's correct. But someone who is *NOT* a follower of the Buddha (i.e., NOT a

Re: [Zen] Re: a puppet on a string

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 yes joe..sometimes the ads are fun..mostly they are boring boring and idiotic..merle   Merle, Cause and effect applies to people, all people. No matter if awakened or not. There is no escape from dependent arising, dependent origination. Several famous koans treat this, and lots of good

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 dear joe..i like the basement ..i like the wine cellar however can it be called the pit?... merle   Dear Merle, Our practice does not result in an acquirement. It results in a loss. When we lose all, we are in the basement. We are below the foundation of all things. It's a good place.

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Suresh, Perhaps ours or yours is a party-line telephone, as in the very old days. It appears you've posted a conversation from elsewhere, by others, and we've picked-up by mistake. BTW, for those interested in THE BOOK OF MIRDAD, the author is Mikhail Naimy. He was a Lebanese Greek Orthodox

RE: [Zen] Re: a puppet on a string

2013-06-07 Thread uerusuboyo
br/Haha, at last! Joe, I want to have your love child...br/br/Mikebr/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

[Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, The notion, the idea, the feeling of it... all dispelled by effective practice. No such-a thing, when you are clear about what there is, instead. We don't *try* to dispel it. But when you're able to look clearly, there's no there, there. There is no mind, either. Is there a heart?

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, If it is the pit, there are no vipers there. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: dear joe..i like the basement ..i like the wine cellar however can it be called the pit?... merle Current Book Discussion: any Zen book that you

Re: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/It's not really a question of why?, rather that on observation there is nothing named a 'soul' that can be found. Where is yours? br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

[Zen] Re: little white lies

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, you're not following the conversation. Are you multi-tasking?, or otherwise challenged? Day-drinking, you say? Suresh takes the utterances of ex- trauma-patients as metaphysical teaching. I say in response that it is more secure to take our own practice as the source of light.

Re: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
that on observation there is nothing named a 'soul' that can be found. Where is yours? Mike Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad From: Merle Lester merlewiit...@yahoo.com; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: the S word Sent: Fri

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 joe..well thank christ for that!..hey joe..how come christ he was enlightened..we all agree..he had no teacher...merle   Merle, If it is the pit, there are no vipers there. --Joe Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote: dear joe..i like the basement ..i like the wine cellar however can it

Re: [Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 yea... gibran... one of my all time favs... merle   Suresh, Perhaps ours or yours is a party-line telephone, as in the very old days. It appears you've posted a conversation from elsewhere, by others, and we've picked-up by mistake. BTW, for those interested in THE BOOK OF MIRDAD, the

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Bill!
Merle and Joe, Here is some 'Cartoon Zen' that supports Joe's point below: ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe wrote: Dear Merle, Our practice does not result in an acquirement. It results in a loss. When we lose all, we are in the basement. We are below the foundation of

[Zen] Re: Who is this non-dual Self? - Consciousness beyond the gross, subtle and causal bodies

2013-06-07 Thread Bill!
Suresh, Although I'm not actually reading these they to seem to resemble the of Dialogs of Plato because of their question and answer format. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, SURESH JAGADEESAN varamtha@... wrote: D - Disciple M - Ramana Maharishi D.: What is this path of

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-07 Thread Suresh
Dear Joe, Of course the discussion was with other forum member. I know the author of The Book of Mirdad. I have posted it since it is also related to Buddha. Since that member thought Buddha also copied from vedas, I have to argue with him. Like you are so much obsessed with zen and zen only,

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
 perfect...thank you bill...merle   Merle and Joe, Here is some 'Cartoon Zen' that supports Joe's point below: ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Joe wrote: Dear Merle, Our practice does not result in an acquirement. It results in a loss. When we lose all, we are in the

Re: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-07 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/Then you must also believe in Scientology's 'thetan':br/br/But Hubbard decided to take the reports of past life events seriously and postulated the existence of the thetan, a concept similar to the soul.[54] (Wikipedia).br/br/If you can't see it, feel it or smell it.. what's the

RE: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread uerusuboyo
LIKE!br/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread uerusuboyo
Merle,br/br/And yet when key Buddhist teachings are mentioned here you say, Bullshit! (cause and effect). and Give me a break (no soul). Which is it to be?br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Merle Lester
; To: Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com; Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: question time Sent: Fri, Jun 7, 2013 11:26:19 AM    perfect...thank you bill...merle   Merle and Joe, Here is some 'Cartoon Zen' that supports Joe's point below: ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Merle, We don't know which teachers or how many teachers Jesus had. Some claim he'd been to India (and back). We also don't really know what his state of mind was: had he stopped at One Mind?, or had he gone further, to No Mind (Zen Mind)? We don't know. Scriptures also are divergent about

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-07 Thread Joe
Suresh, Well, obsessed is too strong -- and wrong -- a word. On a Zen forum, I don't mind speaking about Zen, however. Your habit seems to speak about all else but Zen. Other things enter here from time to time, of course, which relate to our topic. But in general, I enjoy keeping on-topic,

[Zen] Re: The Book of Mirdad

2013-06-07 Thread Bill!
Suresh, et al... I agree with Joe here. In fact zen koans are used to exhaust logic and dialectic. When you try to use logic or dialectic to 'solve' a koan you will continually fail and eventually will just give up out of frustration or boredom - much the way you can relax your mind by

Re: [Zen] Re: Over words humans are separated

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
   imagination suresh... merle   Suresh, I would describe your and the female you mentioned experience of seeing one's own body separate from the body as an hallucination, and certainly nothing important vis-a-vis zen - other than it may have created just another attachment you're going to

Re: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 settle down...when is it permitted to change the subject line then?..is there a hard and fast rule?.. merle   Edgar, I don't see why you think I changed the subject. The actual subject of this thread was the SOUL. If you notice the thread's subject you'll discover that's what the S stand

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 buddha nature bill... you say no god then you say buddha nature..please clarify..thanks ... merle   Merle, Good question... The terms 'zen' and 'atheism' are not the same classes of things. My current working definition of 'zen' (not Zen Buddhism) is: Zen is a human practice that assists

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
  you betcha bill..enlightenment as is karma and buddha nature..they are all mis - used... as is all  that human beings think or feel or do  there is the original then it becomes the chinese whisper game.. of course we could run to the dictionary.. however joe blow in the street..does not

[Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Merle, There is no hard and fast rule - only karma ;) Seriously...all of us do change the focus of posts from time to time. We pick out things mentioned and want to talk specifically about them. When we do change the main subject of a post we should actually change the subject line - but

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Merle, Another good question. Here is my working definition of 'Buddha Nature': Buddha Nature is a quality of all sentient beings. It is pure, unadulterated, holistic awareness of sensual experience. In other words it's just sight, sound, smell, taste and/or touch BEFORE you intellectualize

RE: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-06 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!,br/br/Then the planets are truly aligned ; )br/br/Mikebr/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

[Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Mike, It must be because of our good karma ;)...or it could just be a random event that we've interpreted as good karma - like seeing Jesus' face in a tortilla...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, uerusuboyo@... wrote: Bill!,br/br/Then the planets are truly aligned ;

RE: [Zen] Re: the S word

2013-06-06 Thread uerusuboyo
Bill!, br/br/I always believed that there was no such thing as a random event in the universe. Then Merle started posting..br/br/Mike br/br/Only joking, Merle! You're still my favourite fruit-bat ; )br/br/br/Sent from Yahoo! Mail for iPad

[Zen] Re: Shizan

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Edgar, Unfortunately I couldn't see any picture but I could read the text. I just can't reconcile the things you say with the quote contained within the text: The shining jade pond is a combination metaphor: the still water is the enlightened mind, revealed when the wind (of ignorance) dies

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 the greeks and romans had gods...they were not wise nor good...so what definition of god do you hold to, bill?...merle   Merle, Another good question. Here is my working definition of 'Buddha Nature': Buddha Nature is a quality of all sentient beings. It is pure, unadulterated, holistic

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Merle, 'God' is a mental concept, an invention of the human intellect. That makes it(he/she) an illusion in my book. ...Bill! --- In Zen_Forum@yahoogroups.com, Merle Lester merlewiitpom@... wrote:  the greeks and romans had gods...they were not wise nor good...so what definition of

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 bill..i see so you are an atheist?..  then you tell me there is buddha nature..again i ask what does this mean?...  how does jesus christ fit into the scheme of things?...was he perfection of buddha nature?.. and if so... he says he was the son of god  then was he deluded? how come the

Re: [Zen] Re: Over words humans are separated

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 suresh...  it has been documented before..people watching there own operations..they do not get enough anaesthetics...  the tennis shoe story...how do you know it is true?...  humans like to exaggerate and get attention..they'll do anything, say anything if it means getting attention.. what

Re: [Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Merle Lester
 bill  are we not god's handiwork?...then god is not separate... god runs in your veins and is part and parcel of who you are...as you say buddha nature.. how would you speak to christ if he was on this forum... what would you say: there is no god?..was christ insane when he said he was the

[Zen] Re: question time

2013-06-06 Thread Bill!
Merle, Lots of questions! I've embedded my responses below:  bill..i see so you are an atheist?.. Yes.  then you tell me there is buddha nature..again i ask what does this mean?... And I tell you again: Buddha Nature is a quality of all sentient beings. It is pure, unadulterated,

<    4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12   13   >