Anthony,
Reminds me of the following (supposedly actual dialogue):
During wartime and the slaughter of civilians a general came upon a
lone monk seated peacefully in the midst of the carnage.
Surprised and puzzled the general asked the monk, "Aren't you worried
about dying? I could kill you right now without batting an eye."
The monk responded, "And I could be killed by you right now without
batting an eye."
Edgar
On Jan 14, 2009, at 6:02 AM, Anthony Wu wrote:
Bill,
I fully agree with all you say, but on condition that we live in
paradise on earth, like in the USA, or your part of Thailand, where
you are not faced with killing, war and other kinds of suffering.
When you meet a murderer, and are being killed, can you just 'be
killed'? Then you qualify for a samurai. When you starve with no
money to buy food, can you just starve? What if the murderer is
killing your friend? Do you help him, or just stand by and see him
killed?
Anthony
--- On Wed, 14/1/09, [email protected] <[email protected]>
wrote:
From: [email protected] <[email protected]>
Subject: RE: [Zen] Re: The Reason For God
To: [email protected]
Date: Wednesday, 14 January, 2009, 9:59 AM
Anthony and Mike,
I'm jumping into this discussion to say that I still am not getting
posts from Mike. I read his post attached to this post (Anthony's)
and wanted to say I agree with it for the most part.
As for Anthony's questions below:
- Some examples of what an advanced zen practitioner can do are:
wake when refreshed, eat when hungry, wash your bowls and sleep
when tired. The important part about these are not that they are
remarkable, the important part about these is when you do them, you
DO THEM and ONLY THEM. You don't think about what you're going to
do later when you are eating. When eating, Just EAT! When washing
your bowls, Just WASH YOUR BOWLS! Always, Just THIS!
- The stories you read are just stories - zen stories. Don't try to
intellectualize them. When you read them Just READ!
Read the koan concerning Nanchaun (Nanzen - Jp.) and the cat again.
It's Case 14 in the GATELESS GATE koan collection. The part about
the monks quarreling and the 'killing' of the cat is incidental to
the story. Read the Commentaries and Teisho on the case.
Seung Sahn (Soen Sa Nim) was a contemporary Zen Master in the
Korean Zen Buddhist tradition. His comparison about sex and a
porcupine in a narrow hole may have been meant to refer to any type
of addiction. Maybe he had a problem with addiction to sex. His
comparison may only apply to him and not to you. Again, don't
overly intellectualize his words, and no matter WHO the author of a
quote is, even Gautama Siddhartha Buddha, the quotes are just
words, may be misquoted or awkwardly interpreted, and may or may
not apply to you. In any event YOU are the one who must discovery
Buddha Nature and then you burn all your books.
The other two examples you cite are just extreme examples of
Compassion, a trait that is stressed in Buddhism and is inherent in
Buddha Nature.
Mike, I am not getting your posts via email from
zen_fo...@yahoogrou ps.com. If you post something you REALLY REALLY
want me to read, please either copy me on the email or send me an
alert that you've posted something. My email address I use for the
forum is billsm...@hhs1963. org.
Thanks...Bill!
From: zen_fo...@yahoogrou ps.com [mailto:zen_fo...@yahoogrou
ps.com] On Behalf Of Anthony Wu
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2009 5:44 AM
To: zen_fo...@yahoogrou ps.com
Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: The Reason For God
Mike,
Please give me specific examples of what an advanced zen
practitioner can do, after 'breaking through belief systems and
acting beyond ego'.
I have read:
- Zen Master Nanchuan killed a cat, because it caused a serious
quarrel between two groups of monks.
- Zen Master Sohng Sahn (died a couple of years ago) compared
having sex to a porcupine getting into a narrow hole (too addictive
to get out).
- Monks practisin zen wash their bowls, after having rice, with
tea, then dry them, so that no water is used to save that precious
resource..
- A monk licks maggots on a wound of a dog, for fear of hurting the
maggots and the dog (this may be a myth, but is representative of
certain thinkings)
What do you think of them?
Anthony
--- On Tue, 13/1/09, mike brown <uerusub...@yahoo. co.uk> wrote:
From: mike brown <uerusub...@yahoo. co.uk>
Subject: Re: [Zen] Re: The Reason For God
To: zen_fo...@yahoogrou ps.com
Date: Tuesday, 13 January, 2009, 6:15 PM
Hi Al,
This is not true of Zen at all. A person in a society usually
adopts the beliefs, moral, ethics that have been passed down to him/
her. There is nothing inherently true in those beliefs. Often a
person will face a situation which demands he act in accordance
with his society's moals/religious beliefs but which creates a
conflict with his individual conscience. This in turn creates a
constant 'mulling' over of the situation eg, is it 'just', good or
bad etc. This is the very thing Zen stands against because this
constant thinking and rationalising comes from an ego at war with
itself and the moral beliefs of society (such beliefs are more
often than not an obstruction to executing an immediate action). A
Zen-aware person has broken thru the belief system of his culture
and has become a 'master' of himself and so acts instantly with no
thought of what is 'just', good/bad according to a hegemonic system
that comes from outside of himself.
So, a person acting from the Zen standpoint is far from amoral.
They are always open, present, balanced and acting beyond ego. It
is the taking away of a belief in morals that creates this state
(enlightenment) but which produces behaviour that could be called
'moral' as viewed by most of the worlds major religions.
Mike
--- On Tue, 13/1/09, fitness4u2163 <fitness1963@ yahoo.com> wrote:
Anthony Wu > Karma is the best thing to ensure moral values. As soon
as they hear about moral values, many will say we are just dogmatic. >
It is disturbing to me that many who want to practice zen think it is
some amoral system to ease their conscience every day so they can do
evil to others while feeling a sense of peace and happiness.
____________ _________ _________ _________ _
Get your preferred Email name!
Now you can @ymail..com and @rocketmail. .com.
__________ NOD32 3761 (20090113) Information __________
This message was checked by NOD32 antivirus system.
http://www.eset. com
Search. browse and book your hotels and flights through Yahoo! Travel