Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 4:33 PM, Jouni Valkonen wrote: horace, you have two flaws in reasoning. T3 is inlet water temperature. Not the temperature of output of primary circuit. You are correct, it should be the value what you thought it to be, but this is the main flaw in the test. This also

Re: [Vo]:There are two heat exchangers

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
OK, Jed ! Here's a route to storing energy in molten salts in an insulated container, and releasing it under exact control at choice as late as a week later at 99 % restoration of the stored heat: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_energy_storage Molten salt technology Molten salt can be

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
The Tout thermocouple being within an inch or two of the hot steam flow into the heat exchanger does not sit well w/me... From watching Lewan's video again, the external heat exchanger (XHX) was operated in counter-current flow, where the steam from the primary circuit flowed opposite to the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
Hey, Horace, I don't see anyone calling YOU a pathological skeptic -- thanks muchly for doing my homework for me... Gratefully, Rich Murray On Fri, Oct 7, 2011 at 10:57 PM, Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: On Oct 7, 2011, at 4:33 PM, Jouni Valkonen wrote: horace, you have two

Re: [Vo]:OT: 000

2011-10-08 Thread Harry Veeder
On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 1:36 AM, Terry Blanton hohlr...@gmail.com wrote: On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 1:35 AM, Terry Blanton hohlr...@gmail.com wrote: On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 1:31 AM, Harry Veeder hveeder...@gmail.com wrote: I never completed my secret agent course so I didn't get a positive integer.

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 10:04 PM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint wrote: The Tout thermocouple being within an inch or two of the hot steam flow into the heat exchanger does not sit well w/me... From watching Lewan's video again, the external heat exchanger (XHX) was operated in counter-current flow,

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 10:10 PM, Rich Murray wrote: Hey, Horace, I don't see anyone calling YOU a pathological skeptic -- thanks muchly for doing my homework for me... Gratefully, Rich Murray Well, I am admittedly a member of the free energy lunatic fringe. What would be the point? 8^) I

Re: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Andrea Selva
I think that this frequency generator is just the usual blue box holding the dimmers array that power the heating resistors. Someone (Lewan) probably in error called it in this way and Rossi took advantage of that, as he used to, to spread around even more smoke. 2011/10/8 Jouni Valkonen

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 4:33 PM, Jouni Valkonen wrote: Second flaw in your reasoning is that it pointless to calculate COP from the beginning of the temporarily limited test. That is because initial heating took 18 MJ energy before anything was happening inside the core. Therefore COP bears

Re: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 4:57 PM, Jouni Valkonen wrote: frequency generator was shutdown 19:00, but E-Cat continued runing still some 40 minutes before reactions stopped because of increased water inflow rate. Curiously hydrogen pressure seems not to be that important for E-Cat. It does seem

[Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jouni Valkonen
Horace, you were correct. I did error with the temperature (one example how easy it is to jump into conclusions when you thought to be certain, but actually reasoning was flawed). Temperature after the heat exchanger was indeed measured in primary circuit. But we have just two datapoints which had

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
An extended review of the Rossi 6 Oct 2011 test, with a better format graph, is located at: http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/Rossi6Oct2011Review.pdf Best regards, Horace Heffner http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/

[Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
This has stressed my patience too much and exceeded my deadline. I wait now until Rossi presents a real live demonstration that cannot been discussed. I would expect something like this: All my rooms are heated by a 10 kW gasboiler. The water inflow to my 5 radiators is currently 60°. The

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: An extended review of the Rossi 6 Oct 2011 test, with a better format graph, is located at: http://www.mtaonline.net/~hheffner/Rossi6Oct2011Review.pdf This is an excellent report. I agree with the analysis, conclusions and most of the details. I

RE: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Roarty, Francis X
Jed, I totally agree with your assessment of the review and the quibble over the seemingly anomalous heat gain when power is first removed - the anomaly supports the claim of an ongoing LENR reaction in the reactor where control has suddenly been handed over to a secondary agitator / signal

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread vorl bek
The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the reaction, not to enhance it. I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat from the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how would continuing to heat it after it ignites suppress the reaction? And how would

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Craig Haynie
In any case, it is nonsensical that when power is cut that output power quickly momentarily rises. The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the reaction, not to enhance it. Others have observed that in some cases when heater power is cut, anomalous heat rises rapidly. I

RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Horac sez: On Oct 7, 2011, at 10:10 PM, Rich Murray wrote: Hey, Horace, I don't see anyone calling YOU a pathological skeptic -- thanks muchly for doing my homework for me... Well, I am admittedly a member of the free energy lunatic fringe. What would be the point? 8^) I still am on

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jeff Driscoll
Can someone tell me where the exit water themocouple was located? It meausured a delta T of zero C to approx 9 C during the test. Is there a photo? Could it have been under the influence of an electic heater nearby? Why didn't Rossi make a big tank of hot water? 120 MJ would heat 150 gallons

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Man on Bridges
Hi, On 8-10-2011 16:43, Craig Haynie wrote: I can't help but think back to the idea that it's not heat which triggers the reaction, but rather an event which causes the molecules to vibrate at a certain frequency. I think Znidarsic holds this view and, if correct, can identify the frequency

RE: [Vo]:Bias offset knob on Omega HH12B range is 9 deg C

2011-10-08 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Jed sez: ... On a completely unrelated subject, you might want to see this video of a wild turkey chasing a television producer: http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/us/2011/10/07/turkey-attacks-producer.kxtv That's hilarious! It's great that the TV reporter had the sense to keep videotaping

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Akira Shirakawa
On 2011-10-08 01:28, Horace Heffner wrote: The following is in regard to the Rossi 7 Oct E-cat experiment as reported by NyTeknic here: A knowledgeable user on italian discussion board Energeticambiente.it made a few impressive charts regarding the 7 Oct experiment. Everybody, have a look at

Re: [Vo]:[NET] E-Cat Test Demonstrates Energy Loss

2011-10-08 Thread Harry Veeder
hehe. Harry On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 1:31 AM, Terry Blanton hohlr...@gmail.com wrote: On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 1:14 AM, Harry Veeder hveeder...@gmail.com wrote: It is not outside the laws of conventional physics that some or all of the initial input energy was converted to mass and temporarily

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jeff Driscoll hcarb...@gmail.com wrote: Can someone tell me where the exit water themocouple was located? It meausured a delta T of zero C to approx 9 C during the test. This is shown in the video. I believe it was on the outside of the pipe leading out from the heat exchanger, and it was

Re: [Vo]:Re: July 7th E-Cat test report

2011-10-08 Thread Mattia Rizzi
No, it isn't. He's talking about energy (Kwh) flow (/h) It's amazing that nobody reads the report. He wrote ENERGY PRODUCED. That's not energy flow, is energy produced. ANd it's not a typo, because he wrote it many many times. 2011/10/8 Mauro Lacy ma...@lacy.com.ar On 10/07/2011 10:31 AM,

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Akira Shirakawa shirakawa.ak...@gmail.com wrote: A knowledgeable user on italian discussion board Energeticambiente.it made a few impressive charts regarding the 7 Oct experiment. Everybody, have a look at the following link: http://goo.gl/gm0D0 This links to the message: Analisi Dati

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Akira Shirakawa
On 2011-10-08 17:46, Jed Rothwell wrote: This links to the message: Analisi Dati esperimento FF. This has images andamenti termici.jpg and others. But you have to be member to see them! If the images are small, could you please copy them here? Sorry, here is a link that should make them

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
vorl bek vorl@antichef.com wrote: The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the reaction, not to enhance it. I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat from the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how would continuing to heat it after it

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Akira Shirakawa shirakawa.ak...@gmail.com wrote: Sorry, here is a link that should make them available to everybody: http://imgur.com/a/iwZQ8 Nice! Good graphs! The Internet is wonderful. - Jed

RE: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Jones Beene
In what was otherwise a disappointing demo (due to the missing four hours of the scheduled 12)... and which would have made all the difference between success - and the 'yawner' that we are stuck with ... there is one lingering issue. This 'mystery device,' aka a frequency generator, could be a

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
You are tired of discussions and number crunching? You are in the wrong place. Come back after cold fusion is commercialized and the whole world agrees it is real. Actually, I suppose this discussion group and LENR-CANR.org will be defunct when that happens. Kind of like homebrew computer clubs

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Akira: What does this word rendomento mean, in the Google translation? This is the graph instead of the power output. One sees that the E-cat provides more energy than it consumes but does not rendomento is staggering. - Jed

Re: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 11:59 AM, Jones Beene jone...@pacbell.net wrote: Has Rossi been 'winging it' all along? As conjectured earlier, I think there is a current flow through the reactor material. In another conjecture, I speculated that there could be a sonic or ultrasonic signal which

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Akira Shirakawa
On 2011-10-08 18:16, Jed Rothwell wrote: Akira: What does this word rendomento mean, in the Google translation? It means performance, energy yield/gain. The user actually meant to write rendimento. This is the graph instead of the power output. One sees that the E-cat provides more energy

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread vorl bek
vorl bek vorl@antichef.com wrote: The electric heating power is apparently used to suppress the reaction, not to enhance it. I have never heard of any material acting that way. If heat from the electric heater is used to ignite the nickel, how would continuing to heat it

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Akira Shirakawa shirakawa.ak...@gmail.com wrote: What does this word rendomento mean, in the Google translation? It means performance, energy yield/gain. The user actually meant to write rendimento. Thanks. I think the author is wrong about that. Energy yield or gain is meaningless in

RE: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Couldn't it be the simple explanation in that he's simply running the PWM controller at a very low duty cycle? As part of the teardown at the end, did they open up the blue control box? It wasn't mentioned anywhere that I've read so far. -mark -Original Message- From: Terry Blanton

RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Jeff Driscoll wrote: Could it have been under the influence of an electic heater nearby? To which Jed wrote: There is no electric heater nearby. It could be influenced by the outlet from the condensed steam water, but I doubt it for the following reasons: It was far from that spot; that

[Vo]:Cooling water thermocouples were taped to the outside of the pipe + 20 m hose problem

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Lewan told me that the thermocouples from the handheld meter were taped to the outside of the metal pipe, and then very well insulated. People may complain, but actually that is a fine way to do it, in my experience. In the video, Rossi unwrapped the pipe and showed where the thermocouples were

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
Am 08.10.2011 18:13, schrieb Jed Rothwell: What you demand here is a commercial-product demonstration: Now, install these radiators in free air and measure the water flow and the delta_th and absolute temperatures and log them. Let it run non-stop for 24 hours. This would be a

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
vorl bek vorl@antichef.com wrote: First of all, ignition is only an analogy here. Nothing is or can be ignited or burned in the chemical sense. There is no oxygen. There is no fuel. No chemical changes occur in the cells. Thanks, I needed that reminder. Now I see that pretty much

Re: [Vo]:Re: July 7th E-Cat test report

2011-10-08 Thread Man on Bridges
Hi, On 8-10-2011 17:44, Mattia Rizzi wrote: No, it isn't. He's talking about energy (Kwh) flow (/h) It's amazing that nobody reads the report. He wrote ENERGY PRODUCED. That's not energy flow, is energy produced. ANd it's not a typo, because he wrote it many many times. 2011/10/8 Mauro Lacy

[Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
I can't afford to go to sleep any more. Too many messages on vortex for me to keep up. I am way behind. I had to add 0.8°C to the Tout in order to compensate for the bad thermometer calibration. Here is the spreadsheet with the bias removed:

[Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Gluck
My dear friends, i have tried to describe my opinion re the latest Rossi event here: http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2011/10/seven-skinny-e-cats-eating-seven-fat.html My thanks to all of you who have commented on these forums, first of all to Horace Heffner who has got the essence and the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 8, 2011, at 7:14 AM, Akira Shirakawa wrote: On 2011-10-08 01:28, Horace Heffner wrote: The following is in regard to the Rossi 7 Oct E-cat experiment as reported by NyTeknic here: A knowledgeable user on italian discussion board Energeticambiente.it made a few impressive charts

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Akira Shirakawa
On 2011-10-08 20:41, Horace Heffner wrote: I don't see any charts. What am I doing wrong? Is there a link there I am missing? You are not doing anything wrong. It looks you need to subscribe to that discussion board to see the charts. I've put up a new link for everybody to see them:

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread Robert Leguillon
Do we know how they measured the temperature at the output of the primary? The temperature variations at the secondary look very suspicious (not following rhyme-nor-reason, and taken too infrequently to track trends). Those measured temperatures of condensed steam, at the output of the primary,

Re: [Vo]:Re: July 7th E-Cat test report

2011-10-08 Thread Robert Leguillon
I think the reason for easy confusion is that kWh is not a term that the lay person normally deals with. 1 KWh, or 1 kilowatt-hour, does not indicate 1 kilowatt per hour, but represents 1 kilowatt over a span of 1 hour. Hence, 500 watts for two hours = 1 kWh. The layperson inherently links kWh

[Vo]:RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
As far as I'm aware, there were no measurements taken at the primary circuit's exiting the heat exchanger (the steam condensate)... at least not during the warming up period and self-sustain period. In Mats Lewan's report he did measure the condensate coming out but it was well after the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Harry Veeder
On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 10:43 AM, Craig Haynie cchayniepub...@gmail.com wrote: . I can't help but think back to the idea that it's not heat which triggers the reaction, but rather an event which causes the molecules to vibrate at a certain frequency. I think Znidarsic holds this view and, if

[Vo]:RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
The four thermocouples that I am aware of are: Tin : Secondary circuit INPUT to external heat exchanger Tout: Secondary circuit OUTPUT from external heat exchanger T2 : Primary circuit OUTPUT (steam), thermocouple inserted INSIDE E-Cat) T3 :

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: Yes of course that will convince everyone. I suppose that if Rossi could do this, he would, since he says commercial success is the most important metric. He said he has used it to heat his office. He said this to Kullander and Essen and they

Re: [Vo]:RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread Robert Leguillon
Twice the output of the primary was measured. You won't see it in the spreadsheets(because it was only measured twice). Look in the .pdf file from NyTeknik: At 18:57, the output of the primary of the heat exchanger was supposedly 23.8 degrees. Less than room temp, less than the input OR output

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
Am 08.10.2011 21:42, schrieb Jed Rothwell: Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de mailto:peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: Yes of course that will convince everyone. I suppose that if Rossi could do this, he would, since he says commercial success is the most important metric. He

Re: [Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Peter Gluck peter.gl...@gmail.com wrote: i have tried to describe my opinion re the latest Rossi event here: http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2011/10/seven-skinny-e-cats-eating-seven-fat.html This says: - the primary steam hot water circuit was open and this can mean that the E-cats

Re: [Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
Am 08.10.2011 21:59, schrieb Jed Rothwell: Peter Gluck peter.gl...@gmail.com mailto:peter.gl...@gmail.com wrote: i have tried to describe my opinion re the latest Rossi event here: http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2011/10/seven-skinny-e-cats-eating-seven-fat.html This says: - the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: I expect he did use it to heat an office. That does not mean he knows how to do it again. He has always given the impression, that he can. I do not get that impression. He says he is trying to commercialize as soon as possible. He says that is his

Re: [Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Gluck
*Incrustation is a problem in this circuit.* DGT said they use organic heat transfer agents in this closed circuit. This is a problem of good control. (read please my previous posting predicting the outcome of the Oct experiment. I have NOT told thta the heat comes from some chemistry. I think it

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 7, 2011, at 11:57 PM, Jouni Valkonen wrote: Horace, you were correct. I did error with the temperature (one example how easy it is to jump into conclusions when you thought to be certain, but actually reasoning was flawed). Temperature after the heat exchanger was indeed

Re: [Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: 1. There is no evidence that Rossi could not recirculate the condensate if he wanted to. There is evidence that he did not want or he couldnt. I wouldn't want to if I were him. It sounds like a pain in the butt with no benefit. Suppose for the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Taylor J. Smith
Hi Horace, 10-8-11 I don't understand the two attached captions for your graph. Would you please put them in plain text (ascii) for me? Also, I would appreciate any explanation of the graph you can give me. Thanks, Jack Smith inline: rossi106.jpginline: r2os106.jpg

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
Am 08.10.2011 22:18, schrieb Jed Rothwell: Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de mailto:peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: I expect he did use it to heat an office. That does not mean he knows how to do it again. He has always given the impression, that he can. I do not get that

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Alan Fletcher
Further, the fact the data is highly variable is an indication the hot water arrives at the heat exchanger in slugs. That's my take on it. Best regards, Horace Heffner A BRILLIANT OBSERVATION The eCat's running in the same weird mode as Lewan/Sept ... at 120C 1 Bar (?) 50% fluid

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: The test was advertised to be 24 hours. Then it was advertised to be at least 12 hours. I believe it was the other way around. They said 12 hours, possibly to be extended to 24. Hidden power sources are not needed to explain the results. A

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Alan Fletcher
SA's link to that italian site (thanks!) shows the eCat stable between 110-120C and the exchanger highly variable. http://i.imgur.com/CPyVV.jpg - Original Message - Further, the fact the data is highly variable is an indication the hot water arrives at the heat exchanger in slugs.

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de wrote: bending every effort to accomplish these goals. But I have never heard him say he could be making commercially useful heaters now. Then you do not listen what he says. Examples for this are overwhelming in count and content. One example: A

Re: [Vo]:[NET] E-Cat Test Demonstrates Energy Loss

2011-10-08 Thread Alan Fletcher
Harry Veeder wrote (my Zimbra web mail isn't putting in the sender name ) It is not outside the laws of conventional physics that some or all of the initial input energy was converted to mass and temporarily stored as mass. Usually when we think of E=mc^2 we think of mass being converted

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Peter Heckert
Am 08.10.2011 23:07, schrieb Jed Rothwell: That's January 2012. Not now. This is still 2011. You are talking about what he hopes to accomplish in the future. I am talking about what he accomplished in the past, and what he can do now. From october 2011 to january 2012 is much less time than

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
I pressed send before I finished writing a message. Anyway, I meant to say: It does not matter how wrong the positioning may be, or how inaccurate or imprecise the thermometers are. Inescapably, it would cool to room temperature and all . . . would return to where they were when the test began.

Re: [Vo]:frequency generator

2011-10-08 Thread Terry Blanton
On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 12:51 PM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint zeropo...@charter.net wrote: Couldn't it be the simple explanation in that he's simply running the PWM controller at a very low duty cycle? It's not a pulse width modulator, it's a triac, a AC dimmer. Well technically it does pulse the

[Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
This was shown in the video on the table. Lewan says this was a Termometro a 4 canali TM-947 SD. 4 canali evidently means you can attach up to 4 thermocouples. http://www.bergamomisure.it/parametri-ambientali/termometri/termometro-datalogger-4-canali-tm-947-con-scheda-sd.html - Jed

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Terry Blanton
Heck, back in the Cro-Magnon era of computers, I used to have difficulty making the same object code produce the same result twice in a row. That was with computers, which were supposedly the most predictable, logic-based, closed-universe devices around. Yeah, the hardware was. But the

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 8, 2011, at 12:23 PM, Taylor J. Smith wrote: Hi Horace, 10-8-11 I don't understand the two attached captions for your graph. Would you please put them in plain text (ascii) for me? Also, I would appreciate any explanation of the graph you can give me. Thanks, Jack

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Alan Fletcher
Gee ... so why the heck didn't they use the other two on the steam input and output? - Original Message - This was shown in the video on the table. Lewan says this was a Termometro a 4 canali TM-947 SD. 4 canali evidently means you can attach up to 4 thermocouples. - Jed

[Vo]:Re: [Vo]:RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias

2011-10-08 Thread dwie...@qwest.net
From my Android phone on T-Mobile. The first nationwide 4G network. - Reply message - From: Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint zeropo...@charter.net To: vortex-l@eskimo.com Subject: [Vo]:RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct 2011 Spreadsheet without 0.8°C bias Date: Sat, Oct 8, 2011 1:16 pm As far as I'm aware,

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 8, 2011, at 1:51 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: This was shown in the video on the table. Lewan says this was a Termometro a 4 canali TM-947 SD. 4 canali evidently means you can attach up to 4 thermocouples. http://www.bergamomisure.it/parametri-ambientali/termometri/

Re: [Vo]:Rossi E-CAT: I am tired about discussions and number crunching

2011-10-08 Thread Jouni Valkonen
lauantai, 8. lokakuuta 2011 Peter Heckert peter.heck...@arcor.de kirjoitti: A household sized ecat device is on market in january. Even the costs are known: 2000$/kW that $2000 / kW is not for household devices, but it is for megawatt scale devices. For household devices cost is much much

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jouni Valkonen
Mats calibrated the thermometer and indeed he saw the 1 degree offset in calibration. Temperature of icy water was measured 1.0°C. Therefore this error is known. —Jouni sunnuntai, 9. lokakuuta 2011 Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net kirjoitti: On Oct 8, 2011, at 1:51 PM, Jed Rothwell

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Alan Fletcher a...@well.com wrote: Gee ... so why the heck didn't they use the other two on the steam input and output? And why the heck didn't they use the SD card to record and then publish all data points?!? Instead of relying on Lewan to write down the temperature from time to time. Rossi

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: On Oct 8, 2011, at 1:51 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: This was shown in the video on the table. Lewan says this was a Termometro a 4 canali TM-947 SD. 4 canali evidently means you can attach up to 4 thermocouples.

Re: EXTERNAL: Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread francis
Jed, Good points all but I think there has been a long standing chemical component involved here ever since the day of Langmuir. There appears to be a need for the hydrogen to go from monatomic to diatomic states -maybe not the simple oscillation proposed with the atomic hydrogen

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
Hello Steven Vincent Johnson orionwo...@charter.net , Good to receive your warm, wry, alert comments -- like the smiling hanged man in the classic Rider Tarot deck, hair hanging down, hands crossed behind his back, suspended from a tree by a rope to one foot, the other foot crossed over that

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Jouni Valkonen jounivalko...@gmail.com wrote: Mats calibrated the thermometer and indeed he saw the 1 degree offset in calibration. Temperature of icy water was measured 1.0°C. Therefore this error is known. I discussed that with him. I do not think that was a 1.0°C error. He was seeing

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Jouni Valkonen
Rich Murray wrote: Anyway, Horace's painstaking and thorough critique, thoroughly vetted and improved in candid discussions on Vortex-L, establishes that the demo has not proved excess heat or heat after death. This is surprising. I have spread Horace's (almost) brilliant critique to all

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Mauro Lacy
On 10/08/2011 03:47 PM, Akira Shirakawa wrote: On 2011-10-08 20:41, Horace Heffner wrote: I don't see any charts. What am I doing wrong? Is there a link there I am missing? You are not doing anything wrong. It looks you need to subscribe to that discussion board to see the charts.

RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Horace wrote: Yet a higher than 100°C reading was present for the thermometer inside the E-cat. That indicates a good possibility that this high reading is merely a systematic false reading. Horace, The T2 thermometer (inside the E-Cat) started out at nearly the same temp as the peristaltic pump

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 8, 2011, at 3:10 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: On Oct 8, 2011, at 1:51 PM, Jed Rothwell wrote: This was shown in the video on the table. Lewan says this was a Termometro a 4 canali TM-947 SD. 4 canali evidently means you can attach up to 4

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
On Oct 8, 2011, at 5:15 PM, Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint wrote: Horace wrote: Yet a higher than 100°C reading was present for the thermometer inside the E-cat. That indicates a good possibility that this high reading is merely a systematic false reading. Horace, The T2 thermometer (inside the

RE: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread OrionWorks - Steven Vincent Johnson
Hi Rich, Just a brief comment. You said: ...I am mainly waiting for Rossi himself to come to his senses, do a proper run to show to himself there is no excess heat anomaly, and then promptly share this with complete candor... To be honest I currently don't feel I'm proficient enough with

[Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Horace Heffner
Attached is a jpg of the fitting for the hot end of the Rossi heat exchanger. The finger points to where the Tout themocouple was located. The other side of this big brass fitting was the entry point for the steam/water from the E-cat. You can see white streak marks on the tape both

Re: [Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Robert Leguillon
I saw it in the video, but this JPEG makes it even more obvious. Thanks for the upload. You've got 120+ degrees (allegedly) on one side, and a couple inches away less than 30 degrees. A few degrees of heat transfer is lauded as conclusive, irrefutable evidence of a multi-kilowatt cold fusion

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Horace Heffner hheff...@mtaonline.net wrote: Two thermocouples were used to measure the delta T. If one is off 1 degree hot absolute and the other is off 1 degree cold absolute, then delta T is off by 2°C, systematically. Yes of course if they are both off by 1 degree that's 2. HOWEVER:

Re: [Vo]:Rossi 6 Oct Experiment Data - Preliminary Data Analysis

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
Hi Steven, I am pleased and grateful to appreciate your sincere, frank, and wise sharing -- I mean, like the hanged man, to wait happily, suspended helplessly upside down in my daily dream, appreciating freedom not just patiently but joyfully and securely, within unified awareness-being, for

Re: [Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Jed Rothwell
Robert Leguillon robert.leguil...@hotmail.com wrote: I saw it in the video, but this JPEG makes it even more obvious. Thanks for the upload. You've got 120+ degrees (allegedly) on one side . . . Why do you say allegedly? It was boiling in the cell. It has be over 100 deg C. Add some

Re: [Vo]:Thermometer used to measure cooling water

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
Well, Jed, I hope your're right about there being copious irrefutable evidence in the July 8 demo for an excess heat anomaly -- in that case, we should petition Rossi to immediately release the full details to world authorities, so that the world community can commit to publicly exploring a

Re: [Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Rich Murray
Hello Jed, I recall that Horace described evidence that slugs of hot water, separated by steam, went directly from the exit of the reactor into the heat exchanger right next to the output thermocouple of the heat exchanger -- it is plausible that hot water could create the excess heating of that

Re: [Vo]:Blog comments re Oct 6 Fat Cat experment

2011-10-08 Thread Harry Veeder
On Sat, Oct 8, 2011 at 4:30 PM, Jed Rothwell jedrothw...@gmail.com wrote: His [Rossi's]only goal is to do a test quickly and conveniently that he himself finds convincing. He does not care whether the observers have trouble understanding it. He never listens to suggestions made by experts

Re: [Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Enzo
Two more pictures of the thermocouple (from user agoz on 22passi blog) http://www.redmatica.com/media/Thermo1.jpg http://www.redmatica.com/media/Thermo2.jpg Another user on 22passi (Mario Massa) computed that the thermocouple in that position could give a reading as higher as 5 deg C more then the

RE: [Vo]:Rossi heat exchanger fitting

2011-10-08 Thread Mark Iverson-ZeroPoint
Thanks for posting those pics, Enzo... Like I said yesterday at about this same time... The Tout thermocouple being within an inch or two of the hot steam flow into the heat exchanger does not sit well w/me... Looks like the thermocouple was Less than 2 from the steam-half of the exchanger