Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-09-23 Thread Kanandarqu
(lost track of who wrote what) But if you repeal ALL government mandates, you'll wind up with lots of policies that appear to cover everything a consumer might want, but are actually full of loopholes so that the insurer need not pay for standard treatments. That seems the opposite of

Health care reform: without a correct diagnosis, there is no cure

2009-09-13 Thread John Williams
Jeffrey S. Flier is Dean of Harvard Medical School. In the Journal of Clinical Investigation article referenced below, Flier offers his ideas on health care reform. http://www.jci.org/articles/view/41033 Flier identifies three root causes for the symptoms of America's health care ills: | First

Health Care:

2009-09-06 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
Bruce wrote: What exactly *do* you propose as an alternative to public-option health care for people who aren't fortunate enough to be able to afford health insurance that will actually cover treatments? You didn't ask me; but I thought I'd actually propose something that makes sense. First

Health care reform dead

2009-08-26 Thread tshipley
The Democrats can't close debate in the Senate. Republicans have no incentive to compromise. U.S. health care reform is dead. Sent from my BlackBerry Smartphone provided by Alltel ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l_mccmedia.com

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:32 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Either it will have a higher premium to cover pre-existing conditions, or it only covers things not caused by the pre-existing condition. That is not how health status insurance works. It is insurance against an

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 6:46 PM, Trent Shipleytship...@deru.com wrote: The people outside the boundary are not my responsibility.  They are not my people.  Furthermore, they don't participate in my moral economy. The status of the poor in my country has an immediate effect on me.  I may be

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:42 PM, Trent Shipleytship...@deru.com wrote: So insurance could charge someone with type II diabetes more, but not someone with type I diabetes.  You could charge more to people who, smoke, are over weight, who don't exercise, or who practice un-safe sex. You

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:34 PM, Lance A. Brownla...@bearcircle.net wrote: The analogy between auto and health insurance fails in one regard:  Most of the time, a 5x increase in auto insurance premiums is a direct result of decisions by the covered person.  Many of causes for increases in

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
Original Message: - From: John Williams jwilliams4...@gmail.com Date: Sun, 16 Aug 2009 23:21:45 -0700 To: brin-l@mccmedia.com Subject: Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care Another good reason for heath status insurance John, you realize what you are arguing, don't you

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Charlie Bell
On 18/08/2009, at 12:11 AM, dsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: What you are searching for is akin to trying to find an even prime number. It's really easy to find one... ...but then you go looking for another... Charlie. But There's One, So There Must Be Another Eventually Maru

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 23:18, John Williams wrote: If the government is going to interfere in the insurance market, it seems to me that it would be simpler just to directly subsidize those who cannot afford to pay health insurance premiums, and leave the insurance market to function rationally.

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 23:03, John Williams wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:32 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Either it will have a higher premium to cover pre-existing conditions, or it only covers things not caused by the pre-existing condition. That is not how

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Dave Land
On 16 Aug 2009 at 23:18, John Williams wrote: If the government is going to interfere in the insurance market, You call it interference, I call it participation. Well, at least you don't try to hide your bias. Dave ___

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 7:11 AM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: There is a reason why there isn't affordable long term insurance. Yes, government interference and people who would rather spend other people's money for their own insurance.

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 9:19 AM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Of course that's how it works. It's in the interest of insurance companies not to pay out. Your shilling for corperations is amusing, but not based in reality: insurance allways takes into account risks. No,

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 9:33 AM, Dave Landdml...@gmail.com wrote: On 16 Aug 2009 at 23:18, John Williams wrote: If the government is going to interfere in the insurance market, You call it interference, I call it participation. I'd agree with forced participation. Here's an example of

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
health insurance premiums, and leave the insurance market to function rationally. That is extremely expensive, for all it's simpler. Actually, studies have shown that consumer driven health care reduces costs, and does not decrease preventative care. http://www.actuary.org/pdf/health/cdhp_may09.pdf

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 7:11 AM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: Original Message: - From: John Williams jwilliams4...@gmail.com Date: Sun, 16 Aug 2009 23:21:45 -0700 To: brin-l@mccmedia.com Subject: Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 17 Aug 2009 at 12:51, John Williams wrote: On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 9:19 AM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Of course that's how it works. It's in the interest of insurance companies not to pay out. Your shilling for corperations is amusing, but not based in reality:

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Andrew Crystall
to directly subsidize those who cannot afford to pay health insurance premiums, and leave the insurance market to function rationally. That is extremely expensive, for all it's simpler. Actually, studies have shown that consumer driven health care reduces costs, and does not decrease

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 4:47 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: On 17 Aug 2009 at 12:51, John Williams wrote: On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 9:19 AM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: No, considering pre-existing conditions is not how health status insurance works. It

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
that consumer driven health care reduces costs, and does not decrease preventative care. Except you're not proposing consumer driven health care, you propising that the government pick up an lot of expensive healthcare costs. More, it doesn't create incentives to increase prevenative care

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Jo Anne
to have copious amounts of free time to respond ad nauseum. Did someone say John's been on this list for 10 years? Did I misread that?? I don't remember being this prodded to respond for many years -- probably since JDG was here =+)). Anyway, John, you said health care was an emotional issue for me

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 17 Aug 2009 at 17:06, John Williams wrote: On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 4:47 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: On 17 Aug 2009 at 12:51, John Williams wrote: On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 9:19 AM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: No, considering pre-existing

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
in a large increase in cost of health care, and many of them are not correlated. Having a heart condition is not likely to lead to prostate cancer, for example. So it magically constantly decreases costs? No, read it again - the trend is that it will be 3-5% cheaper than a PPO plan. Interesting

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
Do you think you're fooling anyone with this schtick? I hope not. It is certainly not my intention to fool anyone. ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l_mccmedia.com

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread Nick Arnett
? Competition for consumer business. Is there some way in which consumer-driven means something other than unregulated? Is health care so unimportant that it deserves no regulation? Is health care so unimportant that people should have to compete with each other (that's the other side of the equation

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Aug 17, 2009 at 7:29 PM, Nick Arnettnick.arn...@gmail.com wrote: Is health care so unimportant that it deserves no regulation? We are starting from different worldviews, I think. I believe in freedom for people to make agreements with each other as they choose -- that is my starting

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
Did someone say John's been on this list for 10 years? Did I misread that?? I told John many of us had been. Maybe that got mangled. Maybe by me. :-) Dan M. myhosting.com - Premium Microsoft® Windows® and Linux web and

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-17 Thread John Williams
, my panties are riding up after trying to talk to you about health care, like his did about pollution regulation. He did not try to discuss pollution regulation with me at all -- I would have been happy to discuss it with him, and to clear up the apparent question that he had about me

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
The Atlantic has a thoughtful article by David Goldhill on health care and health insurance reform. It is long, but I think well worth reading. I've also included below a few paragraphs that I thought were particularly interesting. http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/print/200909/health-care

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Ronn! Blankenship
At 02:51 AM Sunday 8/16/2009, John Williams wrote: The Atlantic has a thoughtful article by David Goldhill on health care and health insurance reform. It is long, but I think well worth reading. I've also included below a few paragraphs that I thought were particularly interesting. http

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:05 AM, Ronn! Blankenshipronn_blankens...@bellsouth.net wrote: I'm only a little way into the article, but I take it Semmelwies is no longer mentioned in the medical school (or pre-med) curriculum? I think that the guidelines Goldhill refers to are more systematic and

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
One thing that is often discussed in reference to health insurance is that if someone is unexpectedly afflicted with a chronic condition, their health insurance premiums will usually increase drastically. Health insurance for someone diagnosed with a chronic condition might go from $2,000 a year

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Patrick Sweeney
When you reach a point where the suggested solution to ridiculously overpriced health insurance is to take out an insurance policy on your insurance ... perhaps it's a sign that you ought to consider some other system. Patrick On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 12:24 PM, John

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 12:28 PM, Patrick Sweeneyfirefly.ga...@gmail.com wrote: When you reach a point where the suggested solution to ridiculously overpriced health insurance is to take out an insurance policy on your insurance ... perhaps it's a sign that you ought to consider some other

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread David Hobby
John Williams wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 12:28 PM, Patrick Sweeneyfirefly.ga...@gmail.com wrote: When you reach a point where the suggested solution to ridiculously overpriced health insurance is to take out an insurance policy on your insurance ... perhaps it's a sign that you ought to

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Patrick Sweeney
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 1:47 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: I'd guess that Patrick is expecting health insurance to have health status insurance already built into it. One would think the whole point of health insurance is to provide you with health care (more precisely, the funds

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 1:47 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: It does strike me as a kludge, though.  To continue your example of car insurance, I don't believe that anybody markets insurance against having your car insurance premiums rise dramatically. I do not think there is a as

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 2:05 PM, Patrick Sweeneyfirefly.ga...@gmail.com wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 1:47 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: But if I do fall ill, for the insurer to raise my rates rather than provide the agreed-upon care seems like dirty pool. That is only true if

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 14:08, John Williams wrote: New ideas can be difficult to get used to. Perhaps they could be bundled together for those who prefer it. But it would be a bundle -- the two types of insurance are fundamentally different, since one pays a lump sum or equivalent (like life

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 2:32 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Many people won't go for checkups if they have to pay out of pocket, and they will ignore dangerous conditions for too long. Did you read the article, or just the excerpts I posted? This was discussed in the

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 2:38 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: And immediately you're creating the concept that as aoon as anything happens, your insurance will go up, because the risk to the insurer that you'll not be paying them anymore has been pushed to another party. I

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 14:44, John Williams wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 2:32 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Many people won't go for checkups if they have to pay out of pocket, and they will ignore dangerous conditions for too long. Did you read the article, or just

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 3:34 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Yes, you're simply refusing to accnowledge the actual results of the policys proposed... What exactly am I refusing to acknowledge? to be charged (as their status insurance can be cancelled, Health status

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 15:52, John Williams wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 3:34 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: Yes, you're simply refusing to accnowledge the actual results of the policys proposed... What exactly am I refusing to acknowledge? That you'd simply once

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread John Williams
On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:10 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: , so if you're a bad health risk or have prexisting conditions you're very unlikely to be able to get status coverage at a deacent price or at all in the first place, That is not the way health status insurance

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Andrew Crystall
On 16 Aug 2009 at 16:30, John Williams wrote: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 4:10 PM, Andrew Crystalldawnfal...@upliftwar.com wrote: , so if you're a bad health risk or have prexisting conditions you're very unlikely to be able to get status coverage at a deacent price or at all in the first

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Lance A. Brown
John Williams said the following on 8/16/2009 5:08 PM: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 1:47 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: It does strike me as a kludge, though. To continue your example of car insurance, I don't believe that anybody markets insurance against having your car insurance

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Trent Shipley
Lance A. Brown wrote: John Williams said the following on 8/16/2009 5:08 PM: On Sun, Aug 16, 2009 at 1:47 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: It does strike me as a kludge, though. To continue your example of car insurance, I don't believe that anybody markets insurance against having

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-16 Thread Trent Shipley
because of the belief that everyone should have a chance to live and be healthy, then why not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Why not? The basic reason is that people are both tribal and self

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Lance A. Brown
, did you have an HSA or a health care flexible spending account? Flexible spending accounts have a pre-selected amount of pre-tax dollars set aside that you can then spend on non-covered medical expenses. Those funds expires at the end of the calendar year. I thought all HSA accounts allowed you

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Bruce Bostwick
, with another on global threats and national security, one on the environment, and one on strengthening family life, which would include health care, education, and retirement. I also think there should be one on parts of speech and sentence structure. And one on fractions. -- Toby Ziegler

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Chris Frandsen
in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l_mccmedia.com ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Dave Land
redistribute wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US. But there are charities. And the ambitious (and/or extremely wealthy) can start their own organizations. Why must your desired method involve government? It mustn't

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Jo Anne
, the topic *I'M* discussing is health care in the US. I think these sorts of details should be up to each consumer to decide upon. And I wonder how much of a believer you would become should you, your partner, you children, your parents, etc. be suddenly injured or struck with a long-term/life

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Jo Anne
[Lance] wrote: Jo Anne, did you have an HSA or a health care flexible spending account? Flexible spending accounts have a pre-selected amount of pre-tax dollars set aside that you can then spend on non-covered medical expenses. Those funds expires at the end of the calendar year. I thought

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread John Williams
On Thu, Aug 13, 2009 at 9:41 AM, Chris Frandsenlear...@mac.com wrote:  My generation has become noticeably stingier as our balance of trade swung around from crazy black to very red, starting with Nixon.  Now it appears some do not even think we can care for our own people Our own people? Who

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-13 Thread Nick Arnett
$120 billion into less developed nations, just for health care, in 2006, the most recent year I came up with doing a quick search. Ignoring the existence of foreign aid for health demonstrates either being hopelessly out of the loop in terms of international politics or deliberate omission

A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
People on this list have argued for the advantages of a free market system for health care and health care insurance. I have thought about it, and decided to apply what we know from other markets that have considerable less government intervention. For example, big screen TVs. If you have

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 8:50 AM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: People on this list have argued for the advantages of a free market system for health care and health care insurance.  I have thought about it, and decided to apply what we know from other markets

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l_mccmedia.com

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
to ObamaCare Eight things we can do to improve health care without adding to the deficit: Remove the legal obstacles that slow the creation of high-deductible health insurance plans and health savings accounts (HSAs). Equalize the tax laws so that employer-provided health insurance and individually owned

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/08/consumer-drive-health-care-plans.html Alex Tabarrok wrote: |For about the last 10 years the United States has been experimenting |with consumer driven health care plans. CDH plans typically combine |a high-deductible insurance policy

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Nick Arnett
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 11:32 AM, John Williams jwilliams4...@gmail.comwrote: http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2009/08/consumer-drive-health-care-plans.html Alex Tabarrok wrote: |For about the last 10 years the United States has been experimenting |with consumer driven

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread David Hobby
cover. ... Make costs transparent so that consumers understand what health-care treatments cost. ... John-- Going by the present state of things, the two bullets above seem to contradict each other. I can see why one might object to some government mandates that insurance must cover certain

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Lance A. Brown
not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Straw man. -- GPG Fingerprint: 409B A409 A38D 92BF 15D9 6EEE 9A82 F2AC 69AC 07B9 CACert.org Assurer ___ http

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 12:15 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: John Williams wrote: Repeal government mandates regarding what insurance companies must cover. ... Make costs transparent so that consumers understand what health-care treatments cost. ... Going by the present

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
that everyone should have a chance to live and be healthy, then why not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Straw man. I understand why that question makes you uncomfortable. It makes me

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Trent Shipley
dsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: People on this list have argued for the advantages of a free market system for health care and health care insurance. I have thought about it, and decided to apply what we know from other markets that have considerable less government intervention

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Trent Shipley
not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Why not? The basic reason is that people are both tribal and self-interested. ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
that everyone should have a chance to live and be healthy, then why not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Why not? The basic reason is that people are both tribal and self-interested. Would

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread David Hobby
John Williams wrote: On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 12:15 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: John Williams wrote: Repeal government mandates regarding what insurance companies must cover. ... Make costs transparent so that consumers understand what health-care treatments cost. ... Going

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread David Hobby
because of the belief that everyone should have a chance to live and be healthy, then why not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Straw man. I understand why that question makes you uncomfortable

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 5:26 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: How on earth is the average consumer going to check that their policy is NOT full of loopholes? First, I'll point that I know of no system to ensure that there are not loopholes or other problems with a product or service.

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Dave Land
wealth to improve healthcare because of the belief that everyone should have a chance to live and be healthy, then why not focus on redistributing wealth from people in the US to the people in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US? Why not? The basic reason is that people

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread Jo Anne
Hello Group -- This discussion about health care is driving me a little crazy, as a retired nurse. I agree with Dan, Nick, David and everyone else who sees the need for some sort of universal risk pool. The one thing that irks me about talking about high deductibles and health savings accounts

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 5:33 PM, David Hobbyhob...@newpaltz.edu wrote: This is an old kind of argument that is usually used to support not taking action.  It asks How can you worry about A, when B is so much worse? That was a question, not an argument. And I am not being flippant. My point is

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread David Hobby
information. I agree, that would solve the problem with policies that appeared to cover things and actually didn't. There are other reasons to have universal health care, but there would have to be an element of coercion to the implementation. You seem to be against even taxation, as a matter

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
in the world who have far worse health care than those in the US. But there are charities. And the ambitious (and/or extremely wealthy) can start their own organizations. Why must your desired method involve government? ___ http://mccmedia.com/mailman

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
Compassion, folks. IAAMOAC. I agree with your points Jo Anne, and welcome hearing from you. mail2web LIVE – Free email based on Microsoft® Exchange technology - http://link.mail2web.com/LIVE

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
family would favor a policy with a lower stop-loss. I think if the government reduced most of their interference in the health care market (see some of John Mackey's points in the article I linked to earlier), that there would be a lot more choice for consumers as to what type of health care plan

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
Compassion and government are strange bedfellows. I'd prefer to express my compassion without government. I understand. But, since you expressed it as I am not my brother's keeper, that's what most folks would call no compassion. You are free to express itbut we are free to disagree.

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 7:43 PM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: I understand.  But, since you expressed it as I am not my brother's keeper, that's what most folks would call no compassion.  You are free to express itbut we are free to disagree. Why do we always

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread dsummersmi...@comcast.net
To: dsummersmi...@comcast.net, brin-l@mccmedia.com Subject: Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 7:43 PM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: I understand.  But, since you expressed it as I am not my brother's keeper, that's what most folks would call

Re: A Real Free Market in Health Care

2009-08-12 Thread John Williams
On Wed, Aug 12, 2009 at 10:08 PM, dsummersmi...@comcast.netdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: Well, when you quote Cain as a fudmental moral position, you write words that result in a straight reading of the text leading to that conclusion. Which has now thoroughly been taken out of context, and

Health care (was Re: WeChooseTheMoon)

2009-07-30 Thread Nick Arnett
the power to compel people at gunpoint to do as they say. Government lawmakers do. That is a huge difference. So is the difference between criminal and civil law. So put away your gun-toting straw men - nobody is talking about criminalizing private health care. They're not even talking about making

Health care is civil law, not guns involved (Re: WeChooseTheMoon)

2009-07-30 Thread Nick Arnett
On Sun, Jul 19, 2009 at 9:21 PM, John Williams jwilliams4...@gmail.comwrote: I have posted articles that list a number of state mandates for health care plans. If a provider were to dare to sell a policy to a willing buyer, and that policy did not, for example, cover acupuncture in certain

Health Care Spending

2009-07-19 Thread John Williams
On Sat, Jul 18, 2009 at 10:56 AM, Dan Mdsummersmi...@comcast.net wrote: How did you get 1.2 trillion for Medicare and Medicaid? I meant to write that Medicare and Medicaid _and other government-related health care spending_ make up more than half. The biggest additional component is the tax

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same topic all week!~)

2008-11-04 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Nov 3, 2008 at 9:21 PM, Doug Pensinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The alternative might not seem any better, but for the money I'm pretty sure it couldn't be much worse, and I think its high time we try something else. Your experimental system is highly inefficient. Don't you think it

Re: Balancing the bad actors (was Re: Health Care (the same topic all week!~))

2008-11-04 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Nov 3, 2008 at 9:56 PM, Doug Pensinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: John Williams wrote: If less government regulation is better, why do are national health systems prevalent in many parts of the world? Why are wars prevalent in many parts of the world? Why do women love shoes? 3

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~)

2008-11-04 Thread John Williams
On Mon, Nov 3, 2008 at 9:27 PM, Doug Pensinger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Why would it have to be restricted to a numerical scale? Couldn't you be polled on a range of issues to determine where the government was succeeding and where it wasn't? Did you read the original post? A decision is made

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~)

2008-11-03 Thread John Williams
Not even if they asked and you told them? How happy are you on a scale of 1 to 10? No, I don't think I'd trust my answers on that. Compared to what? Myself in the past? That would be hard to judge. Other people I know? Even worse (how do I know how happy they are?). And how to know how much of

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~)

2008-11-03 Thread Wayne Eddy
From: John Williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Killer Bs (David Brin et al) Discussion brin-l@mccmedia.com Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 12:18 AM Subject: Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~) Not even if they asked and you told them? How happy are you

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same topic all week!~)

2008-11-03 Thread Ronn! Blankenship
At 02:26 PM Monday 11/3/2008, Wayne Eddy wrote: From: John Williams [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Killer Bs (David Brin et al) Discussion brin-l@mccmedia.com Sent: Tuesday, November 04, 2008 12:18 AM Subject: Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~) Not even if they asked

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same topic all week!~)

2008-11-03 Thread Doug Pensinger
Ronn! wrote: So what do you do if the present system is badly flawed but the only proposed alternative does not seem any better? (e.g., the named in the previous subject line) If you're talking about heath care, maybe having tried the one system and pretty much universally come to the

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~)

2008-11-03 Thread Doug Pensinger
John Williams How happy are you on a scale of 1 to 10? No, I don't think I'd trust my answers on that. Compared to what? Myself in the past? That would be hard to judge. Other people I know? Even worse (how do I know how happy they are?). And how to know how much of the happiness is due to

Re: Balancing the bad actors (was Re: Health Care (the same topic all week!~))

2008-11-03 Thread Doug Pensinger
John Williams wrote: If less government regulation is better, why do are national health systems prevalent in many parts of the world? Why are wars prevalent in many parts of the world? Why do women love shoes? Doug non sequiturs r us ___

Re: Democracy (was Health Care / The same damn topic all f-ing week!~)

2008-11-02 Thread Doug Pensinger
John Williams wrote: 1) Why trust the government with measuring something as abstract as happiness, if it can be measured at all? I don't think I'd trust even my closest friends and family to measure my happiness. Not even if they asked and you told them? Doug

Balancing the bad actors (was Re: Health Care (the same topic all week!~))

2008-11-01 Thread Lance A. Brown
Ronn! Blankenship said the following on 11/1/2008 12:24 AM: At 11:05 AM Friday 10/31/2008, John Williams wrote: Lance A. Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] Instead, we are faced with actors who will collude with each other to manipulate markets, subvert systems, and for the short term gain without

  1   2   3   >